From: Russ George
* Clearly Rossi has released more than sufficient for those skilled in
the art to reproduce his work(s) and the anomalous heat.
LOL - Not on this planet. Except for Parkhomov/Sochi, there is nothing that
approaches scientific replication of Rossi, and nothing from Rossi himself with
real data unless as Rothwell implies, he has chosen to hide it. Read Tom Clarke
or Bob Higgin’s appraisal of Lugano. There was nothing there out of the noise,
according to Clarke.
* You specify in your endorsement of Ahern that he has reproduced Rossi
as well as others. So how is it you have seen ‘no proof’ from Rossi.
Read much? As the post states - Brian reproduced Arata/Zhang and found excess
heat in his EPRI report. He did put considerable effort into trying to
replicate Rossi, as have dozens of others. However, he could not reproduce nor
could Jack Cole, nor could Jeff Morriss, nor could Alan Goldwater, etc etc and
half a dozen other null results and rather large expenditures of time and
money. I can see you have not kept up with this field, so why am I wasting time
arguing.
Your posts are proof positive that you are engaging in semantic
trolling. Such childish and/or senile grumblings about Rossi’s ‘independent’
verifiers is pure nonsense for anyone with experience in developing
technologies.
Speaking of trolling and senility – are you looking in a mirror? Why not start
by reading the posts that you chose to respond to - before a further
embarrassment of yourself.
* Rossi is following well established traditions in his work and indeed
is far more revealing than virtually any pioneer technologist at this stage of
the game.
Complete nonsense. Sounds like it came from a shill. What are these vague and
deceptive traditions you speak of? Certainly not the open and progressive
traditions of Tom Passel or anyone at SRI.
From: Jones Beene
Wait a minute. What is the need for a secret, when there is no scientific proof
of an anomaly? I have seen no proof from Rossi, have you?
Let Rossi prove through an independent third party that there is a valid
thermal anomaly in the E-Cat, then Ahern can be criticized for complaining
about not knowing the secret of the anomaly.
From: Russ George
It seems Brian is revealing his curmudgeon characteristics. He is clearly
frustrated and petulant that Rossi won’t give him the secrets of his e-cat
master chef recipes. There are very good medications for the treatment of
senile agitation these days.
