In reply to  William Beaty's message of Mon, 28 Aug 2006 14:41:03
-0700 (PDT):
Hi,
[snip]
>One big possibility is that they've discovered a way to make magnets
>slowly demagnetize themselves while they also inject KE into a rotor.  In
>the interview above, they mention that they haven't proved whether the
>energy is coming from the electrical energy that was originally used to
>magnetize the magnets.
[snip]
Assuming that NIB magnets have an energy density of about 40 MGO
(this is actually on the high side I think), then we can easily
compare this to the figures they have already provided:-

i.e. 500 mW/cc for "weeks". Assuming only 2 weeks we get a figure
of ~6E5 J/cc = 7.6E7 MGO. A factor about 2 million times greater
than the energy density of the magnets. Unless I seriously
misunderstand magnets, then I think this rules out energy stored
in the magnets during their creation.

(MGO = Mega Gauss Oersted, an energy density measure).
Regards,

Robin van Spaandonk

http://users.bigpond.net.au/rvanspaa/

Competition provides the motivation,
Cooperation provides the means.

Reply via email to