If found another explanation about electron capture from an expert as
follows:

See below for a "borrowed" explanation from Jim Swenson at the Argonne
National Labs (from their Ask A Scientist program):

"If an electron with enough energy collides with a proton, then what
happens?
They just form a hydrogen atom?
Or they form a neutron?
If both are possible, then which factor controls the process?
I am asking because I heard that a neutron can decay to a proton and an
electron and the reverse is possible.
-----------------
To form a hydrogen atom, it is required that the electron and proton have
almost no energy, almost no velocity relative to each other. A hydrogen
atom ionizes at less than 20 electron-volts of energy, so reverse
ionization requires energy less than about 20 electron-volts (eV) AND
freedom and luck to radiate a photon of the right energy to render the
electron "captured". It happens all the time in every electrified gas lamp
(fluorescents, neons, mercury-arc, etc), and in the surface layers of the
sun.

When a neutron decays into a proton, electron, and neutrino, it also
releases energy, 780,000 eV, as the sum of the kinetic energy of the 3
particles.It is unreasonably difficult to get 3 separate particles to
collide simultaneously, so the exact reverse of this never happens to a
significant extent. It is particularly difficult to get the ghost-like
neutrino to react on command with an electron and proton. Neutrinos are the
particles that sail all the way through the earth, almost never bumping
anything.

However, it is not so difficult for a balanced neutrino / anti-neutrino
pair to be accidentally made out of pure excess energy, from the collision
between an electron and a proton. Then you have the situation of the
electron and proton and neutrino in the same place, merging to form a
neutron, and an anti-neutrino flying away free carrying any excess energy
(beyond the 780 keV that was needed to make up the neutron). I think this
is one of the processes which together make sun-sized masses of neutrons
when a neutron star is formed in a supernova explosion. Actually, in that
situation the electron and proton are steadily squeezed together by
pressure of others around them. Increasing pressure and temperature can
smoothly change the energy of repeated collisions until the best energy is
found, and the conversion becomes quite rapid and energy-efficient.

If the excess energy of collision is over 1,000 keV, other random particles
might be made from the energy too. It only takes 1,020 keV to make an
electron-positron pair, for example. I'm not sure what it takes to start
emitting excess energy as gamma-ray photons. That might happen too.

Jim Swenson"

>From this answer, we need a neutrino to be around and in the party when the
electron and the proton combine. That is not likely to happen unless the
neutrino is made out of energy. The chance of that neutrino production from
energy is the chance that the reaction will work.


The energy of a collision between an election and a proton must be real
close to 780,000 eV to happen. Such precision just don't happen in the real
world.  The chance of that energy being just right is very low. If the
energy is not perfect, other particles will form instead or a gamma will
form. But the point that kills the electron capture idea as the driver of
the LENR reaction is that electron capture must happen 10^23 times a second
to make any heat. That is impossible. Not when the electrons are carrying
the energy of soft x-rays into the collision.

Reply via email to