Dear Jed, Rossi explains why he does not publish ERV-1 now.
But IH? If ERV-2 makes Rossi checkmate, why they do not publish it now - as a fatal blow, great ace in the dispute? It will be interesting to see how it demonstrates lak of excess heat for a complete year. Messy affair Peter On Wed, Apr 13, 2016 at 11:17 PM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com> wrote: > Ian Walker <walker...@gmail.com> wrote: > > 1) First of all according to what Jed Rothwell reports it was commissioned >> solely and apparently secretly by IH with obvious risks of bias. >> > > I did not say anything remotely like that! I just said IH sent experts, > they wrote a report, and their report disagrees with Penon's. > > What did you expect they would do? Do you think they going to pay $89 > million without sending experts or without writing their own evaluation? > > If it were secret why would they tell me they wrote it? (They did not > provide the actual report to me.) > > > >> 2) It breaks the contract, there was an agreed team and an agreed format >> for the ERV contractually agreed and paid for by both parties. >> > > As I said, only a lunatic would enforce a contract that gives Penon the > sole decision making power, with no appeal to technical accuracy or common > sense. As I said, he could write a report saying only: > > "I hereby certify that this reactor produces anomalous heat with a COP > exceeding 6. Please remit $89 million." > > > Do you think a court would enforce that? > > > >> 3) By Jed Rothwell's own post it seems the report is at best partial and >> by its clan-destined nature likely to be flawed. >> > > The Penon report is way more likely to be flawed. The guy is a certified > idiot. > > > >> Why IH are open about this and other aspects worries me greatly. >> > > You should worry about why Rossi refuses to give his report to anyone > after he repeatedly promised to Mats Lewan and others that he would publish > it. His reason for withholding it, which I described in another thread, is > nonsense. He has been working on this lawsuit for a while. If there were > any truth to this claim that his lawyer told him not to publish, the lawyer > would have told him that weeks ago, when Rossi was still promising he would > publish. > > It is just an excuse. > > - Jed > > -- Dr. Peter Gluck Cluj, Romania http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com
