Dear Jed,
I'm sorry if I missed this in an earlier exchange, but I'm very curious
to hear your stance on this especially in light of the events of the
last month.
With all the information that you have been privy to especially over the
last few weeks, what is your stance on the "Rossi Effect" - does it exist?
Also, do you believe that he has been purposefully making fraudulent
claims these past several years?
Lastly, do you believe that he has ever been able to achieve a LENR in
any of his tests either internal or external?
Joe
On 4/14/16 11:25 AM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
Ian Walker <walker...@gmail.com <mailto:walker...@gmail.com>> wrote:
As to the supposed ERV 2 we have seen no proof it exists. In fact
the first we hear of it is from Jed, who then starts to back-pedal
quite a bit about it.
I am not back pedaling about anything! This is nonsense. I never meant
to say there is an official second report. I said the lawsuit filing
lists 3 people involved. One of them works for I.H. I.H. strongly
disagrees with the ERV report. They made that clear in their March 10
statement and in their response to the lawsuit.
The Penon report claims the device produces 80 times input. That is
what Rossi said in his lawsuit. I.H. emphatically denies that.
Obviously their experts reached a different conclusion, as you see
from their press releases. You do not need me to tell you that.
Why is any of what I just said controversial? You can read the press
reports and see for yourself I am right. You know darn well what I mean.
You may be convinced that Rossi is correct and IH is wrong. But you
have no business saying that I am back pedaling or that I have no
reason to say what I just said.
In my opinion, anyone who thinks that Rossi is better at doing
calorimetry than the experts at I.H. does not know either party. There
has to be a drastic mistake here and I am sure Rossi is the one who
made it, since he is prone to dangerous, stupid, sloppy mistakes, such
as the one that almost killed the NASA people.
I also stand by my opinion of Penon, based on his 2012 report. He is a
certified idiot. Read the report and decide for yourself, but don't
tell me I have no basis for my opinion.
- Jed
