Hi all Should have included this in the above text.
Source for what "Jed Said" My apologies. Kind Regards walker On 14 April 2016 at 17:40, Ian Walker <walker...@gmail.com> wrote: > Hi all > > In reply to Jed > > "... as I said. I.H. says > > they disagree with the report. They say there is no heat. That makes the > report valueless. I trust I.H.'s expertise in calorimetry more than I trust > Penon's." > > 1) Who at I.H. said this? > 2) Who is the expert at IH on Calorimetry that you trust so much, that you > accept their credentials? > 3) How did this "expert" physically perform their tests? > 4) How many days of the Test running did they have access to the plant? > 5) When did they decide that according to their calorimetry that the plant > was not working? > 6) What are their qualifications? > 7) Can you point me to a nuclear plant they worked on? > 8) Can you point me to a report on LENR they have done in the past? > > Just the beginning of questioning your assertions. > > Kind Regards walker > > > On 14 April 2016 at 16:34, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> Ian Walker <walker...@gmail.com> wrote: >> >> >>> On another point; and by way of admonishment. If you are going to report >>> something in the future state the source and quote what they say, otherwise >>> you will find yourself entrapped again and once again having to back-pedal >>> the fantasy. >>> >> >> EVERY DAMN THING I SAID can be confirmed in the press releases and legal >> filing. I pointed to these sources again, and again and again. >> >> LOOK HERE Ian!!! You are free to disagree with me. You can say that in >> your opinion I have misinterpreted the press releases, or I do not >> understand what the legal papers said about the 3 people who made the >> evaluation. You can say that for thus and such reason, you think Rossi is >> right that the machine is producing 80 times input, and the I.H. experts >> must be wrong. That would all be fine. But DO NOT accuse me of hiding my >> sources of information when I have repeatedly listed them here. That is >> rude and it is against the rules. It is damned annoying. >> >> I don't mind being told I am wrong, but I resent it when you ignore what >> I say, and accuse me of saying things I did not say, and doing things I did >> not do. Stick to the facts, please. >> >> - Jed >> >> >
