Thanks very much Eric for the pointers to the other papers and for the link to 
your interesting paper too.

I have a lot to catch up with it seems.

I was wondering if the transmutations and isotopic evolutions could turn out to 
require certain states such as excitation or parity spin states or some more 
subtle conditions that might help inform about a higher level external process 
or environment . Rather than first looking at external processes and seeing how 
they affect the nucleus.

But I have a lot to read to catch up with most of you here who have been doing 
this for years and probably have already considered this approach.

Sent from my iPhone

On 16 Sep 2016, at 15:11, Eric Walker 
<<>> wrote:

On Fri, Sep 16, 2016 at 5:25 AM, Stephen Cooke 
<<>> wrote:

This [using Norman Cook's theory as a guide] would be a bottom up approach from 
first principles which might the match well with one or more of the more usual 
top down theories ideas.

This sounds like a top-down approach, starting from some assumptions about 
what's going on and then interpreting the data.  What I was thinking of was a 
bottom-up approach, where one keeps theory out of the picture as much and just 
catalogues what's been found.  Ed Storm's "Science of Low Energy Nuclear 
Reaction" gives a good high-level overview, but it doesn't go into sufficient 
detail.  After reading that book, it's probably good to start looking at actual 
experimental papers.  There are several authors that have repeatedly reported 
them over the years, including but not limited to these ones:

  *   Iwamura
  *   Mizuno
  *   Saavatimova
  *   Karabut

Reading their papers is a good start.  Although transmutations are all over the 
map, there are a handful of possible patterns that could be followed up on 
more.  Here is a speculative attempt I made not at systematizing the data but 
at guessing at what's going on:  Because 
it was speculative, one shouldn't draw any conclusions from it.  Also, there's 
a section on Rossi that is unfortunately probably incorrect and should be 

What I would have loved when I was writing that paper was a reliable 
systematization of the transmutation research, which goes into great detail on 
what's been reported without introducing theoretical considerations.


Reply via email to