Maxwell’s demon is usually interpreted to imply some kind of sorting  mechanism 
which discriminates among particles in order to produce at least two 
populations which vary in a desired property.  The property does not have to be 
heat – here is one based on photonics.
https://phys.org/news/2016-02-physicists-photonic-maxwell-demon.html

There have been many systems which are proved to sort and separate on a small 
or quantum scale. The Ranque Hilsch vortex tube is one which can operate at 
high power levels and gave this forum its name. If the mechanism doesn’t sort 
and separate - then it probably is not a “Demon”.



From: Chris Zell

If you gain from ambient heat, is that a Maxwell’s Demon sort of violation?

Reply via email to