This is the famous Paneth and Peters work which they later withdrew - after 
receiving much criticism. They were trying to replicate Tandberg who claimed a 
new way to make helium which was in great demand for Airships. Deuterium was 
not yet discovered.

P&F were fully aware of all of this. 



Frank Grimer wrote:  
 
 How interesting. One wonders what prompted them to look for helium in the 
first place.Was it ordinary hydrogen or heavy hydrogen?


Nigel Dyer wrote:

  
While looking for an article in a a copy of Nature from 1926 (as you do) I came 
across the following article describing how small quantities of helium had been 
seen when hydrogen was absorbed into palladium at room temperature. There is 
nothing new under the sun.
https://www.nature.com/articles/118526a0?fbclid=IwAR3cI0_tWhMXny-_5VwiIZBr-OmiXLocmzd7gWgBCC1LKNtPHOShckdpUD4
 
The article I was really looking for was one of the early Klein papers on there 
being a fifth dimension, following up an idea that this might be part of the 
explanation of how hydrogen gets converted to helium.
 
 
 
  

Reply via email to