Jed Rothwell wrote:

Russ George sent me a press release which has been published at several sites on the web, including this one:

[snip] "to slow the catastrophic decline of ocean and terrestrial
ecosystems driven by the escalating surplus of CO2 emissions from fossil fuels."

For the sake of balance, let me add a 'biting' counterpoint.

Any true environmentalist (or 'green-investor') should be suspicious of this press release. The whole operation seems to be cloaked in misrepresentation and mystery. It definitely seems far removed from being a nonprofit, or even a for-profit with lofty goals for society, but rather- from all external indicia - seems closer to vehicle for personal enrichment.

For instance, one would have expected that a group whose purpose appears to be focused on raising money for "greener solutions" (and we do not know if that purpose really goes beyond fund-raising for its own sake, or not) would have been able to state the problem, the solution, and most of all the "mordida" a bit more openly.

In actuality, both ocean plankton and terrestrial plant life do benefit, and benefit greatly, from "the escalating surplus of CO2 emissions from fossil fuels". That is not the problem.

The problem, at least insofar as the oceans are concerned, is that CO2 which is *food* for plankton, is less soluble in warmer water.

IOW - from the perspective of algae: CO2 - good; Warmer Oceans - bad

If the ocean temperature, especially in higher latitudes, goes from 20C. to 30C. the amount of CO2 which the water can hold - drops from 1745 ppm to 1345 ppm- this is massive! It means that the warmer ocean can support over 25% less plankton than the colder ocean. Will "fertilization" help there?

The solution of ocean fertilization with minerals (iron) ore is well-known, and seems to have been co-opted by this company under the guise of IP from a true non-profit which is never creditied - but even if the ultimate aim is totally above-board: should that solution be relegated to any for-profit company?

What do they add, other than needless overhead (the mordida)? It is somewhat like those infamous charities who exist ostensibly to raise money for starving orphans in Africa but the beneficiaries end up getting 10 cents on every dollar collected, and the collectors enjoy the rest.

As far as planting more trees - DUH ! - this has been on the "green" European agenda for over 100 years, and seems to be a gratuitous PR ploy to make the outfit look greener, and more like a real environmental group.

OK - so why quibble ?

... It's all about honesty and true motivations - in the era of limited governmental funding. Color me highly suspicious, but all of this PR makes one wonder exactly what the true agenda of "Planktos Corp. (OTCBB:PLKT) of San Francisco and Vancouver" really is ?

One thing for sure: it does involve "green".

Jones



Reply via email to