This is a PR release about a company that has never
shipped actual product, but has thrived on raising
capital from investors and nothing more. 

I hope and pray it is not a scam but I have an
associate in Palo Alto who knows the situation and who
is suspicious, since the actual factory where these
panels are to be made appears to be ficitious. Try to
find a spec sheet. How many products do you know of
which will be shipping soon and no spec sheet exits?

The very same "impossible" claims for a nonexistent
product are being made by Brady/Perendev in Germany
concerning his fuelless magnet generator, yet no one
has seen prototypes and no one can find the supposed
factory. You can invest however, or prepay for a unit.

It is concievable that Nanosolar has discovered little
more than a very sophisticated version of 'pump and
dump'  -- and little else. IOW they have taken the
"hydrogen fuel cell scam" of Ballard and the others to
the next level. It is not really a true scam since
there is a product, it is just a scam in that the
assertions of marketablility are unrealistic.

The basic unsaid problem with Nanosolar is the rare
element that they need in their panels, indium.  5
years ago when Nanosolar started raising its $100
million in VC - indium wasn’t terribly expensive at
about $90/kg. With the advent of LCD flat panel
monitors,  the demand for indium has skyrocketed,
reaching a peak of about $1000/kg. This blows the $1
per watt out of the water, but the CEO is NOT even
mentioning that problem ! The worldwide production of
indium is really quite small and outsiders cannot even
get it excpet in small quantities.

Ask youself this: does Nanosolar have a secret source
for cheap indium? Why did the PR release not even
mention this. Where is the factory?

This is scarily reminiscent of the VC scene
surrounding fuel cells 6-7 years ago, when hunderds of
millions werre pumped into that niche on the same kind
of shallow promises. Ballard was the darling of Wall
Street. Everyone thought Ballard could make them
without platinum or palladium. Nada. The price for
hydrogen fuel cells is higher today than ever.

Do a google search for actual prices of solar cells
which you can buy, and you will find nothing even
close to these pomises now- and then try to find out
where this factory is located... the one where
Nanosolar will be producing these panels "later this
year." If it is in silicon valley, I will volunteer to
go down there and try to get a tour. Do a google
search for [Nanosolar "Chris Eberspacher"] and ask
youself 'why would the chief scientist leave now ?'

I hope that this is cynicism on Nanosolar and printed
photocells in general is unwarranted, but in this case
...  like Cervantes, I smell a rat.

Jones




--- Michel Jullian <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

>
http://earth2tech.com/2007/07/30/10-questions-for-nanosolar-ceo-martin-roscheisen/
> 
> 
> Quote:
> 
> Q). In the thin film industry there are several
> players like Miasole or SoloPower that are looking
> to build the next CIGS thin film technology. What
> will make the difference in which technologies win
> the deals?
> A).An IEC-certified panel product available in
> near-term 100MW volume at a fully-loaded cost point
> in the sixties [cents/Watt] or less so that one can
> profitably sell at a $.99/Watt wholesale price
> point.
> ...
> Q). Will Nanosolar begin production this year?
> A). Yes, we're on track with this. Do not expect an
> Apple style product launch though. Our first 100,000
> panels are already set to go into closed, private,
> utility-scale deployments, with a tall fence around
> them and not much accessibility to the general
> public.
> 
> End quote
> 
> --
> Michel
> 
> 

Reply via email to