Harry Veeder wrote: > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Stephen A. Lawrence" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> >> And a good thing, too -- central governments canNOT be trusted with >> thepower to create money. > > Basically what you are saying is that the American people can't trust > themselves. > Remember "government of people for the people by the people"? Not exactly -- it's a *representative* democracy, not a pure democracy, and the representatives don't have exactly the same interest as the electorate. For the bureaucrats, as for the elected representatives, the ability to add more government programs without the need to raise taxes to pay for them is a major temptation. In a pure democracy, where everything was decided by referendum, things might be different, but AFAIK there aren't any of those in today's world. >> All the incentives are wrong, and >> hyperinflationtends to be the result: The government, as the >> biggest debtor, is also >> the biggest beneficiary of inflation. The Fed, though not perfectly >> independent, is distant enough that the President can't just order up >> another half-trillion in notes whenever he needs to pay the troops. > > > Your government just ordered up more than a half trillion in a few weeks! No they didn't. As it stands that's a transfer payment, and will come out of everyone's hide as either a huge bulge in the bond market (which will in turn tend to push interest rates up) or a boost in taxes on *something*. Alternatively it will result in cuts in programs. Bernanke may decide that the dangers of deflation are looming so large that it is worth the inflationary risk to *monetize* that portion of the national debt by buying the bonds which are issued to pay for it, in which case it may be effectively wiped off the books. But President Bush can't make that decision on his own -- and neither can Congress. >> Only the Fed can do that, and the Fed tends to be at least a little >> under the thumb of big business and big banks, and they generally hate >> inflation. (Contrast this with the situation in Zimbabwe, where the >> government controls everything.) >> > > This is not 1929. It is not 1941. It is not 1973. In the current "credit > crunch", it already looks like a deflationary spiral is of greater > concern than an inflationary spiral. I agree. In fact, the recent reduction in the federal funds rate to 1% does indeed come paired with an inevitable increase in the money supply -- dropping that rate typically results in pushing more money into the banks, and reducing the amount they keep on reserve, and that in turn increases the "multiplier" effect on money which the fed adds to the economy. Throughout the mortgage mess the folks at the Fed have been trying to find ways to address the exact problems which we're facing without lighting the fuse on inflation again. This is difficult, since wars are inflationary, and the galumpfing price of oil is inflationary (blame Bush for the former, certainly, and the latter, to some limited extent); however, with the recent collapse in prices it does seem like they need to turn the ship around and head the other way. Dropping a great lump of cash into the economy, via the Fed's open market desk (which I how I *think* it's normally done -- been a long time since I studied this), might be the right move at this point. These folks aren't dumb, though, and I'm sure they've thought a lot about that. But they are also no doubt painfully aware of the Nixon Stagflation era, when everyone learned that the (empirical but highly respected) Phillips curve was bullshit. > > Harry >

