----- Original Message ----

> From: Terry Blanton 

> Or should I say a "Stirling Segway".  If it burns, it's biofuel:
 
> http://www.cleantechblog.com/2008/11/being-dean-kamen.html


This is only mildly creative, since there is no true spark of genius - yet. 
There is little doubt that Kamen is a good inventor - "good but not great" 
perhaps - but this episode may be rather telling for how he is remembered by 
history, since the Segway is/was such a yawner; 

... and it could end up as reminiscent of something that happened forty years 
ago - with no less a great inventor than Bill Lear. 


In 1968, Lear began pumping money into a steam turbine to
power cars - what was he thinking? - and he did build a steam-powered bus that 
nobody wanted. And in the end, he had blown millions (of profits from the Lear 
Jet, etc) on this failed venture, back when a million was really worth 
something <g>.


It was clear to almost everyone in Detroit that yes, steam would work if it was 
closed-cycle, so that you did not need to carry 50 gallons of water to get to 
Wal-Mart - but where are you going to place 100 square feet of radiators on the 
family car? ... plus even if you could find the space for radiators - what have 
you really gained? The diesel is almost as efficient as the steam turbine to 
begin with.

Maybe, in retrospect I should restate the above - to opine that Lear was a good 
inventor, like Kamen in many ways, but not a great inventor. 


A great inventor will be one who can get our cars off of fossil fuel elegantly, 
and with little downside accomodation.


Jones

Reply via email to