Steve Krivit wrote:

Storms responds, Krivit responds:

http://newenergytimes.com/v2/blog/?p=126#comment-7388

Why? Why respond, that is? And why post unimportant comments from private discussions? I see no point to it. If the people at CMNS want the discussion closed, why not honor their wishes?

Seriously, who cares what Storms said at CMNS? If he has anything important to say that he wishes to share with the public, he will publish it sooner or later. What's the rush? Why reveal people's passing comments and half-baked, unfinished work? This is more like voyeurism than journalism. You can make anyone look bad by quoting them out of context, incompletely, or before they finish editing a paper.

This is a tempest in a teapot but I can see why Storms finds it annoying. (Maybe I would not be so sanguine if Krivit were quoting me out of context for some weird political mind game. Anyway, my policy is I never write or say anything I would hate to see made public. That's how you have to do things in Internet era. Privacy as we once knew it no longer exists. That's a shame but that's how things are, so live with it. People didn't have much privacy before the 18th century anyway, so we are back where we started.)

- Jed

Reply via email to