On Mar 4, 2011, at 3:13 PM, [email protected] wrote:
Hi Horace,
I have been thinking about trapped electrons, and I am not sure
they are trapped
at all. My reasoning is as follows, please correct any errors.
I assume you mean "correct" from the perspective of my deflation
fusion theory. I don't have time right now to correct this with
regards to what I consider wrong theories like W&L. In fact I was
about to depart vortex for a while. It appears most everything
constructive to be said about Rossi's demo has been said. I became
active to contribute to that discussion. Certainly I've said all I
care to. At this point it seems best to wait and see what happens
with the installed unit over a years time, or maybe much sooner.
I'll use the following reaction as an example:
Ni62 + H -> Cu63 + 6.123 MeV
In Cu63 there are no electrons in the nucleus (normally), so the
binding energy
we have for Cu63 isn't what it would be with an electron in the
nucleus.
When an electron is in the nucleus, it masks (compensates for) the
charge of a
proton, so the repulsion of that proton to all the others doesn't
exist.
Not necessarily, and certainly not from the perspective of my
theory. It is only necessary for the wavefunctions of the proton and
electron to have a sufficient probability of simultaneous
wavefunction collapse upon the target nucleus. What happens post
collapse is another thing entirely. To be clear, it is not the
repulsion of that proton from the others which creates the energy
deficit. On the contrary, it is the very fast joining of the proton
to the target nucleus via the strong force that unites the
*attraction* of the Z protons to the electron. It is the radius r of
the joint wavefunction immediately post collapse which has most to do
with the energy deficit ΔΕ:
ΔΕ = (Z-1) (1.44 x 10-9 ev m) / r
as derived and described here:
http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/CFnuclearReactions.pdf
and calculated in brackets, under the *very conservative* assumption
that r is the radius of the compound nucleus of mass Z, in the report:
http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/RptB.pdf
including for:
62Ni28 + p* --> 63Cu29 + 6.122 MeV [-1.984 MeV] (B_Ni:28)
As I clarified, it is useful to think of the deflated state as a
physical state, a cloaked state, or "masked" state in your terms, of
the proton (or deuteron) involved in the long range tunneling which
is only possible for a net charge zero ensemble.
That means that when such a masked proton enters the nucleus the
energy gain is
larger than 6.123 MeV because the nuclear binding force is not
opposed by the
proton repulsion.
Not true. Once the new nucleus is formed by the strong force it's
strong force binding energy, and binding energy release, is
determined. However, the electromagnetic energy involved is *not*
determined, because the size of the composite wavefunction at the
moment of collapse is not determined and, as I suggested in my
theory, it is a random variable.
It is only once the electron has left that we are left with
Cu-63 which was the end product in the reaction above.
The nucleus is formed by the strong force. The energy from the strong
force binding is well known from naked high energy kinetic reactions
which form the proposed compound nucleus. The electron has only to
momentarily move beyond the radius of the new compound nucleus to be
free of it for the purposes of estimating the mass of the compound
nucleus - based on your principle of "proton repulsion". I propose
the motions of the electron trapped near the new nucleus produces
radiation, but not in one or two photons, but in the form of numerous
photons. This further increases the trapping energy.
So what I am trying to
say is that 6.123 MeV is what is left over *after the electron has
left the
nucleus*, not what is left over with the electron still in the
nucleus.
But that is an inherent and explicit part of my theory. I account for
the electron's ability to leave a nucleus, (even) when there is net
negative energy, by the ability of the electron wavefunction to
expand via energy supplied by the zero point field. There is no
inherent conservation of energy in each cold nuclear, LENR, transaction.
You can also see this by doing the following:
1) Convert the initial H atom into a neutron by adding 782 keV.
H + 782 keV -> n
This kind of pre-reaction is not part of my theory.
2) Add the neutron to Ni62 creating Ni63.
Ni62 + n -> Ni63 + 6.837 MeV (as gamma radiation)
Totally irrelevant. This kind of explanation, if correct, should
also apply to Pd + d reactions. It provides no insight into the
experimentally observed missing energy of heavy element LENR, or the
highly skewed branching ratios of cold hydrogen fusion. The gamma
radiation does not occur. To get a better feel for the energies
involved see:
http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/PdFusion.pdf
Note that in the above report the radius r was reduced to r = 0.85*
(1.25E-15 m) * A^(1/3) ], because that should be roughly the average
radius of a thermalized electron trapped in the nucleus. I think
initially, the radius is much smaller, and the deficit very large due
to the ensemble involving an electron-quark wavefunction.
At this point one essentially has the situation where both
proton and
electron are in the nucleus together, except that 782 keV has been
added when
converting H to neutron.
3) Allow the Ni63 to decay to Cu63 expelling the electron as beta
radiation.
Ni63 -> Cu63 + e- + 67.9 keV (this is where the electron leaves
the nucleus)
At this point we have the same result as in the first reaction,
i.e. the
electron is now outside the nucleus.
The net energy balance is as follows:
-0.782 MeV (negative because we had to add it to create the neutron)
+6.837 MeV
+0.068 MeV
----------
+6.123 MeV = reaction energy from the first reaction (as one would
expect).
In short after H has fused with Ni62 and the electron has left the
nucleus there
is still 6.123 MeV left over, hence the electron is not trapped, in
fact there
is enough energy for the electron to leave the nucleus and still
have 6.123 MeV
left over.
I think this is precisely the kind of thinking that prevents any
understanding of cold fusion. I'll explain why below.
That means that when a masked proton reacts, the electron could carry
the reaction energy rather than it coming out in the form of gamma
rays.
Not true. It is a function of the size of the composite wave
function upon collapse.
That
isn't the case with a neutron because the neutron first has to
undergo a slow
weak force reaction, whereas a masked proton is essentially still
two separate
particles, and no weak force mediated reaction is needed to
"create" the
electron.
Regards,
Robin van Spaandonk
http://rvanspaa.freehostia.com/Project.html
You seem to have have missed the importance of the key points of my
theory. Your argument is essentially based on conservation of
energy. There is some evidence that conservation of energy is
violated, or a least appears to be violated, due to interaction with
the zero point field. If you argue that my theory can't be true or
makes no sense because of conservation of energy, then you are a
priori dismissing my theory, which is explicitly based on the premise
that conservation of energy, at least from a local point of view,
does not apply. Neither does thermodynamics apply, because the
systems involved are, at their most fundamental level, open systems.
I should also note again that I think the *weak* reactions that occur
as a result of deflation fusion primarily involve electron capture
which occurs post strong force reactions, and which further add to
the energy deficit by about 0.7 MeV. Also, the fact that electron
capture of a "tunneled in" electron occurs, part of the deflated pair
coming from outside the target atom, as opposed to an electron which
is part of the high Z target atom's atomic shells, prevents auger
electrons and high energy x-rays from the electron capture. This
accounts for the extreme lack of high energy signatures from various
heavy element LENR reactions.
Understanding my theory is perhaps easier given my *interpretation*
or impression of the nature of quantum wavefunction collapse. I
recently posted some material on that here:
http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg42574.html
Best regards,
Horace Heffner
http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/