On 04/23/2011 01:53 PM, francis wrote:
On Sat 4/23/11 Mauro wrote
[SNIP]
The proposed explanation is as follows:
1) Light is not "pushed" by the emitting device. It leaves the emitting
device as a perturbation in the medium, and propagates at a fixed velocity.
That velocity is dependant only on the medium, and is c when the medium is a
vacuum. 2) The receiving device is also moving, in the same direction as the
emitting one(they are solidary, fixed on the same experimental setup). 3) If
the whole experimental setup is moving(due to earth's rotation and
translation, tipically) the receiving device will be going farther from the
emitted ray in some cases, and towards the emitted ray in some other cases.
Because, as we said before, the emitted ray is independent of the emitting
device's velocity. That way, absolute motion will be detected in the
direction at which the time delta is greater. The light ray will take
longer, travelling at a fixed velocity, to reach the receiving device,
because the travel distance in that direction will be greater. Again,
because the receiving device will be moving away while the light ray is
travelling towards it.
If this is not the case, we must postulate that the movement of the emitting
device affects the velocity of the ray of light. And therefore c is not
constant. Or, we must postulate that the medium is moving solidary with the
experimental setup. And we have detected ether entrainment.
Take notice that I'm not talking about relativistic effects, because there
are none. The emitting and receiving devices are both solidary. That is,
their relative velocity is zero.
[/SNIP]
Mauro,
I have only read the Consoli& Constanza abstract so far
http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0311576 and was looking at the pdf when your
new thread arrived so I will first reply to you and then delve further into
the paper you recommended. I don't agree that measurements from your device
would vary with direction other than mechanical limits of perfectly matching
multiple light sources and measuring devices but I have to admit that I
haven't yet studied these "lesser" deviations that you mention which were
measured in the M&M experiment or their significance. You seem to imply a
much lower than expected difference was measured but I am not clear on what
significance you ascribe to these values. The biggest hurtle with your
alternative measurement remains that we are already at the limit of
measurement devices using fringe patterns. I can see the merit of your
relative measurements to any pattern CHANGES as you rotate the device
between the X,Y,Z axis, It could easily mitigate what we saw gravity do to
the measurements last year of a vertically designed M&M fixture - but I am
unsure if the opposite fringe patterns would have any meaningful static
relationship to each other -your hope would be a min/max measured beam delay
in one orientation that reverses to max/min measured beam delay when you
reverse the orientation?
Yes. I'm propossing using light detectors and synchronized clocks(very
precise clocks) to measure
the differences in departure and arrival times in one-way travel,
instead of using interferometers in two-way travel.
I suggest you to take the time to reflect on the experiment, and to
evaluate the possible outcomes and its consequences.
Reading about the Sagnac effect is probably also a good idea.
The proposed experiment is probably not easy to perform, because of the
needed precision and stability of the clocks. Although it must
be feasible, given current technology.
I would not expect any changes at all since my
premise is that any spatial direction is 90 degrees displaced from time so
spatial direction becomes unimportant and only changes in velocity if
measured relative to another inertial frame would reveal changes in the rate
at which the ether intersects with our spatial axis. Perhaps measuring
changes in the half lives of radioactive gas caused by a catalyst or the
propagation time of a laser through the lower energy density of a Casimir
cavity would reveal more about the ether and it's orientation than revealed
by the M&M technique. I still refer to the ether as having an "orientation"
even though it remains forever in a hidden dimension from within one's own
inertial frame because we know that highly accelerated objects shift to a
different angle between time and space from our perspective and that
proportional to their velocity those accelerated objects perceive as normal
space that which to us appears as the non physical time axis. In the case of
vacuum energy suppression I posit this angle to always be 90 degrees while
with relativistic travel it remains the Pythagorean relationship between
V^2/C^2. I do agree with your statement that there are no relativistic
effects because your devices are fixed to a common axis and you are not
comparing measurements made while being accelerated at different values or
experiencing different equivalent accelerations due to changes in
gravitational value -disregarding the negligible like lunar effects on the
gravity field in your lab.
Regards
Fran