>From Richard: > I examined the video frame by frame for the 15 frames > that were part of the 15 seconds that showed the end > of the black hose -- several frames clearly show the > water mist expanding as a cone directly from the end > of the hose -- thus no proof that invisible steam made > it to the end of the 3 m hose. > > Examine the posts by Joshua Cude for clarifications by > one far more capable than me... > > Every day so far is another day without clear-cut proof > of actual excess heat output...
Rich, maybe you are not aware of the fact that Josua himself has claimed that the video wasn't clear enough to make a definitive conclusion. I specifically asked Josh about the visual quality of the steam emanating from end of the hose as depicted in the video. Here is Josh's response to my query: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg48912.html > "I don't think the quality of the video is good enough > to judge that." I've noticed that you have openly praised Mr. Cude on several occasions for his alleged expertise in debunking Rossi's claims. Joshua certainly seems to have become your hero. Well, maybe Josh really is smart. And maybe he really is a hero... against the claims of all those rabid "believers." Heck! Josh even claims my reasoning on the matter violates conservation of energy. See: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg48947.html Still, I'm not convinced Josh is entirely correct. Others have contested the steam claims as well. But I've already said my piece, so I'll let it go. Nevertheless, what concerns me about Josh is the fact none of us really knows that much about who he is. Where does he comes from? What are his motivations? OTOH, there is someone we DO know a little more about than Mr. Cude, and that person is Dr. Robert Park. Some time ago I suggested to Joshua that he might want to contact Dr. Park in order to get his take on Rossi's claims. I suggested to Joshua that he might want to ask Park why is it that he has remained completely mum on the subject. Six months have now transpired and Dr. Park continues to remain silent, at least publicly. How come someone who seems to have made it one of his personal vendettas in life to publicly attack all cold fusion claims is now curiously silent on the matter? Meanwhile, Mr. Cude (whoever he is) wants to attack Rossi's claims, and you want to champion him as a commendable hero. Something here doesn't add up. For now, I think I'll reserve a definitive conclusion on the Rossi matter. Regards Steven Vincent Johnson www.OrionWorks.com www.zazzle.com/orionworks
