I think it is fine that eventually an influential and powerful organization "asks" Rossi to perform Perfect Experiments. And I also hope he will be obliged to test individual E-cats instead of that monstruous combination of 330 E-cats. With such an impossible set-up everything is possible. Peter
On Thu, Sep 1, 2011 at 9:53 PM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com> wrote: > Peter Heckert wrote: > > - Although Rossi initially complained about it, he agreed to perform tests >>> without phase changes (no steam) >>> >> I dont understand this. The devices where tested all the times with steam >> successfully. >> So they should be tested with steam . . . >> > > Many people prefer to avoid the phase change. There has been considerable > contention here about this issue. The devices have also been tested with > liquid phase, and Rossi told me that his one megawatt device is intended to > heat water only, not to produce steam. > > Defkalion runs all of their reactors in liquid phase only, albeit not > usually water. > > > > Never change a working experiment! >> > > That is a good rule of thumb. However, as I said these devices have been > tested with liquid phase only. Rossi prefers steam because it is easier, > more convenient, and he is sure that the result is accurate. since other > people do have some doubts about this I think it would be diplomatic to use > liquid phase calorimetry. > > As you said, there is something to be said for using both methods. > > > > So far I have read, scientists where invited for late october. Are their >> any news about this? >> > > Rossi told me he would announce the detailed schedule at the end of > September. > > - Jed > > -- Dr. Peter Gluck Cluj, Romania http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com
