Susan Gipp wrote:
I'm sure that for Rossi numbers are pretty meaningless. He often use
them just as nice words to emphasize his speeches. We don't have to
take them to make calculations.
Let's talk instruments (when they work properly)
No, let's talk human reflexes. At around 18:00, someone touched the hose
going to the heat exchanger. That person jumped back because the
connection with hot. that was four hours after the power was turned out.
No matter how you analyze it, there is no way any part of the system
could have been even warm at that time, unless there was kilowatt levels
of heat being generated in the system. people also held there hands over
the reactor and determined that it was very hot. Again there is no way
this could be true unless heat was being generated inside the reactor.
Let us talk human hearing. People heard boiling inside the reactor. four
hours after the power was turned off.
You do not need to believe Rossi and you do not need to believe any of
the instruments to be sure the thing was producing anomalous heat. You
have first principle irrefutable proof right there, in what the
witnesses felt and heard.
It would be nice if we had more reliable instrument readings, but we do
not. However, that is no reason for us to ignore witness accounts, or to
imagine that a person who is burned and feels pain has not touched
something hot. Do not let your anger at Rossi cloud your judgment and
make you ignore first principle proof.
You should look at the evidence you have, not evidence you do not have,
or that you wish you had instead.
As it happens the Rossi numbers are not meaningless. As I just showed
you can reconcile the condensate flow rate with the inlet and outlet
temperature readings. It is likely that the outlet temperature was
affected by the steam pipe, but that the effect was small and the
numbers are basically correct. Instruments such as the Termometro meter
are extremely reliable and there is no way Rossi could open up to meter
and change it so that it produces fake numbers. Instruments such as this
have microelectronics, like digital watches, and the only thing you can
do is break them.
- Jed
