begin quote <<Modern theories of boiling

In the traditional theory of boiling in physics and physical
chemistry, the boundary between the liquid state and the gas state is
sharply defined as the line on which the vapor pressure (function of
temperature) reaches the level of the external pressure. This is as
shown in a typical phase diagram on the right. The assumption of the
sharpness of the liquid-gas boundary theoretically precludes the
variability of boiling point under fixed external pressure; this means
that there is no obvious way of accommodating the observed variations
within the traditional physical theory.

In modern treatises on boiling in mechanical and chemical engineering,
we do not find the standard thermodynamic phase diagrams. Instead, the
engineer’s paradigmatic representation of boiling is the “boiling
curve”, which plots the rate of heat transfer against the degree of
the “surface superheat” or the "excess temperature". The figure on the
left shows a typical boiling curve, taken from Incropera and DeWitt
(1996), p. 540. (Click on the picture to see a larger version with
readable text.) The boiling curve shows a couple of important things
about the incommensurability between the physicist’s and the
engineer’s understanding of boiling. The main independent variable in
the engineering discourse is how much the temperature of the heating
element exceeds the "normal" boiling point. I assume that the water in
immediate contact with the heating element (what De Luc called the
"first layer" of water) is also heated beyond the normal boiling
point. By how much, we cannot really say -- it would be extemely
difficult to measure such a thing and, presumably, the engineers are
more interested in variables that they can measure and control, like
the temperature of the heating element. Therefore, in the best modern
theory of boiling we have, the temperature of the water itself has no
role to play! >> end quote

more...

http://www.hps.cam.ac.uk/people/chang/boiling/discussion3.htm

Reply via email to