On Mon, Dec 26, 2011 at 3:19 PM, Aussie Guy E-Cat <[email protected]>wrote:
> What no comment on this: > > "My change of mind was a direct result of talking with Dr. Dennis > Bushnell, the Chief Scientist for NASA Langley who has assured me that over > 100 experiments worldwide indicate that LENR is real, capable of producing > energy much greater that chemical reactions, with minimal radiation" > I'd be happy to comment after Mr. Opdenaker confirms he wrote it and allows questions. At the moment, it's nothing but an unverified email exchange with a Mr.X, an unidentified party, on a weird believer-oriented web site full of silly comments from obviously ignorant participants. It's also a web site whose owner is unknown. I will say immediately that Dr. Bushnell is entitled to his opinion but until he shown the most spectacular experiments and answers the critiques to them, believing anything because he says so is simply an "appeal to authority" logical fallacy. Far as I know, Dr. Bushnell has not repeated and independently confirmed any of the experiments. If he had, and had done so properly, his opinion, if the quote is accurate, would be worthy of more consideration. Meanwhile, I'd think you'd want to put pressure on Defkalion and Rossi to get independent testing. Defkalion seems to keep promising it without producing it while Rossi keeps prattling about anonymous customers and a million E-cats to the public this coming year when nobody EVER has been able to prove they got a SINGLE E-cat.
