At 01:29 PM 7/9/2012, Chemical Engineer wrote:
Axil,
My concern is that rossi is reading the same technical papers you
are and making claims that fit the theories so your comparisons will
always seem reasonable. We are at the point that we need
independent hard data that he and DGT have managed to generate
thousands of times more power than others.
Accurately stated, though with an incorporated assumption.
"We need." Yes, we need that data if we are to come to firm
conclusions. Whether or not we need firm conclusions is a personal
matter. I don't. I can muddle along for the rest of my life without
this possible energy source, and without knowing if Rossi's reactor
truly generates significant power.
The problem is that Rossi et al don't *need* to provide us with that
data. We aren't paying them. They have no obligation to us.
Some players are scientists or others not playing for personal gain.
They may have needs, but I don't see that Rossi is about to help them
meet them. He doesn't care about them, he's shown that again and again.
I'm just pointing out what's so, and sometimes what is possible, an old habit.
