Ha! I should have read the errata before I posted !!! They come to the same conclusions.
Inner Cylinder Hypothesis • The inner cylinder hypothesis are wrong when it comes to radiation. • The inner cylinder will only radiate from the area of the cylinder opening At least it proves I'm awake ! ----- Original Message ----- > > http://www.scribd.com/doc/105322688/Penon4-1 > > http://www.scribd.com/doc/105325449/Hot-Cat-Data > > http://www.scribd.com/doc/105326231/Corrections > > They assume that : > > > the energy radiated by the INNER cyclinder is identical to that of > > the OUTER. > > I think that > > a) They assume it's all radiative (Though they comment on the air > layer!) > b) The ends are ignored > > Surely NO power will be radiated by the inner cylinder : anything > radiated from one side of the inner will be absorbed by the other side > of the inner. (For simplicity, assuming that each point radiates > orthogonally only). > > Where's ... what's her name ... ? They really should have run a > charged and an uncharged (blank) to calibrate their measurements).
