There are two kinds of ethers.

First: the classical ether is extremely stiff medium where light waves are
propagating, similarly like sound waves are propagating in a water. It must
be hugely stiff, because the speed of light is depended on the stiffness
and the speed of light is quite remarkable.

There is slight problem that if ether as stiff that it allows the speed for
light to be 300 Mm/s, then how on Earth there can be inertial movement
around the sun! And if ether does not interact with regular matter, then
how come we can see the light that is pressure waves propagating through
ether?

Luckily this classical ether was refuted by Einstein and his (with little
help from Planck) invention of quantum theory that pointed out that
actually photons are quantum particles, not waves. And as they are
particles, no ether as medium for light waves is required.


Second: The other kind of Ether is Newton's fixed background or preferred
frame of reference. Einstein developed this idea even further when he
showed with general relativity that actually ether is not fixed, but the
gravity can modify the geometry of absolute frame of reference.

Einstein himself called correctly his general relativity as ether theory as
it is based on a idea of an absolute frame of reference.


In some other instances I have promoted Lorentz's theory of relativity.
That is similar ether based kinematic theory as general relativity is for
accelerating frame of references. That is, the kinematic motion in
Lorentz's theory of relativity is always measured in respect of ether and
if we choose Earth's gravity field as preferred frame of reference, then
this interpretation agrees with every empirical observations so far.

Although Lorentz's theory of relativity is ether theory, it has not
been disproved and it happily agrees with M&M experiment and all the time
dilation observations. Therefore this latter kind of ether, where ether or
preferred frame of reference is Earth's gravity field, is not refuted.

–Jouni

Reply via email to