On Sat, Mar 23, 2013 at 5:27 PM, <[email protected]> wrote:

> Now let the
> entire ellipse swing around the focus like a hoola hoop. We have a second
> form
> of angular momentum (l). Note that the electron itself is still following
> the
> original trajectory around the perimeter of the ellipse as well, so it now
> has
> two forms of angular momentum. Remove it from the atom altogether, and it
> has
> neither.
>

Interesting idea regarding an angular momentum from the precession of an
ellipsoid probability distribution around the nucleus.  According to
Terry's link [1], the putative electron spin will always either be aligned
with or against a magnetic field. What's to make this kind of precession
not be a spherical one, e.g., such that the movement of the ellipsoid over
time rather than being planar instead cancels out any magnetic moment?

[1] http://www.chemistry.mcmaster.ca/esam/Chapter_4/section_2.html

Reply via email to