On Thu, May 30, 2013 at 12:13 PM, Jed Rothwell <[email protected]>wrote:

I’m a Professor Ameritus in Electrical Engineering ... Everything I read in
> the 29 page report, and following challenges as answered by the authors,
> seems extremely convincing. All objections, typically suggesting fraud, are
> not to me at all convincing. Tomorrow will tell!
>

(Facetiousness warning.)

It would seem he must not have been a very good professor, then, given that
he has passed a positive judgment on a manifestly sloppy paper.  He should
speed himself to the nearest physicist and receive guidance.

Eric

Reply via email to