On Wed, Feb 12, 2014 at 12:52 PM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

As a skeptic I demand that another independent group of scientists
> replicate the results.   How do we know that the input power required to
> run the lasers is accurately measured?  The list of possible errors is a
> mile long for an experiment this complicated.
>

The important point that I think we've missed is that the scientists
carrying out this research are *qualified* scientists.  For this kind of
scientist, independent replication is not necessary, because they have
sufficient skill to carry out an experiment whose results one can trust.

About the recent milestone, if I may be allowed to move the goalposts a
little:  now the challenge is to get continuous OU operation, producing
enough energy to recuperate the investment in hardware and people operating
the system.

Eric

Reply via email to