Just a note to some of the newer Vorts who may be wondering how moderation
works in Vortex.  Vortex is moderated, but only very lightly.  The list
relies heavily upon the self-discipline of members to keep a courteous tone
and to moderate the amount of their own contributions.  Ideally the tone of
the list would be that of academics at a Starbucks during the personal time
of a conference -- polite, letting the conversation go where it will, not
necessarily hewing to the rigor of the conference but at the same time
avoiding issues that are contentious.  This is just an ideal, and it is not
always observed.  Sometimes weeks or months can go by where a user or two
will have their way with the forum, posting a string of flamebait and
personal attacks and trying to wrench discussions in the direction of their
own choosing.  This strategy is obviously not an effective one for winning
people to one's point of view.  Almost invariably such people get tired of
posting to Vortex, and those that don't will eventually be cleaned up by
Bill Beaty when he gets around to it (it can take a while).  In the
meantime such individuals must be suffered.

The best strategy to keep the signal to noise ratio high and to avoid
getting caught up in arguments during such periods is filter out the emails
of the problematic individuals.  In Gmail, this can be done by setting up a
filter.  There are different options, and one is to have emails from
certain email addresses automatically marked as "read," so that they do not
grab your attention.  If enough people do this, the people imposing on the
list may get the hint and either moderate their participation or go away on
their own.

Eric

Reply via email to