Re: [Vo]:Pomp weighs in

[Alan Fletcher]

I have to admit that it would be trivially easy for an apprentice 
magician to construct a container into which you insert (say) white 
powder as "fuel" and later on extract black powder as "ash".

But the calorimetry stands.
Pomp doesn't even denigrate the calorimetry : he just ignores it 
"Because none of the measurements presented on the previous 26 pages matter ..."