Bob Cook wrote. "Glass is not a black body in my estimation, and I would expect it to look
different at any given temperature from a true black body."

Having looked inside 100 operating glass melters at temperatures ranging from ambient to 1500C, at any temperature where things start to glow there is not much visible difference between the various materials. For example at 1500C everything looks blindingly white, the molten glass surface, the silica superstrucxture, the AZS refactory side walls. There must be some differences because one can still make out the edges of the refractory blocks and batch piles floating on the molten surface.

It seems to me there is more a difference in brightness than color between 1400 - 1500C. Things start looking red at much lower temperatures. I would quess the E-Cat in the famous photo was 700-900C


Jed, I agree with what you wrote about flow calorimetry being difficult. It would have been sensible to get confirmation of the temperature, at least at one spot, by a thermocouple. I wonder if we have the whole story. That number of people working that long should have figured out some way to confirm the temperature indicated by the camera. I know I would. FOr one thing, I have found the geopmetry of the surface upsets the readings and the surface sure wasn't flat.

Reply via email to