Dirk, > > In my repository I have a branch creation, executed with the exact > > above SS command line, that results in no less than 141 svn > > revisions ! > > > This is interesting, normally the code can do "folder creations" and > "copies" in one go. So we should have a look here in depth. I'm > wondering, why the comment is missing on the copy. Is it also missing > in the share node from PhysicalAction? I have a lot of places like this, > and they all work fine, but I think I also never use comments, when > doing these kind of actions. Need to try.
Just had a look in my PhysicalAction.tmp.txt file. The comment appears only on the ADD project actions (those appear twice, the comment is only on one of the two) and not on the SHARE actions. > > Interestingly I have another branch point where no comment was > > supplied : vss2svn manages to squeeze it into only 2 svn revisions, > > though it is not clear why everything did not fit in a single > revision. > > > I expect, that you have a file that is shared within your project, so > it will end up to be copied two times. The current "revision break" > detection logic will detect, that there was already an operation on the > first share and will force a revision break on the second. I already > tried to solve this, but this is very complex, since the revision > detection logic is at the wrong place in the code. It comes before the > ActionHandler and here we do not have enough information about the real > activity. Good catch, there was indeed a shared file within the project. > > Still, this is an awful lot of activity for something that could > > have been represented as a single > > > > svn cp /MainProject /Branches/MyFirstBranch -Mcomment > > > Yes, this would be wonderful. I also thought about this already and > dismissed the idea due to complexity. And also due to lack of time ;-) Well, that's too bad. I just wanted to make sure that this had crossed your radar, so to speak. Cheers, --Jonathan _______________________________________________ vss2svn-users mailing list Project homepage: http://www.pumacode.org/projects/vss2svn/ Subscribe/Unsubscribe/Admin: http://lists.pumacode.org/mailman/listinfo/vss2svn-users-lists.pumacode.org Mailing list web interface (with searchable archives): http://dir.gmane.org/gmane.comp.version-control.subversion.vss2svn.user
