|
Uri Avnery explains why the problem is not just Sharon, it is just as
much the so called opposition parties, including Labor and Yahad, Yossi Beilin's
party. He suggests what an opposition come to life would be
like--
Take part in the daily battles on the ground
Fight against the monstrous wall
Oppose Natenyaho's Thatcherist economic policy which hits
the poor
Fight against the settlements
Fight the Separation Wall which imprisons the Palestinians in
ghettos
Expose the falsehood, “We Have No Partner for
Peace”
Oppose annexing the “settlement blocs”
Stop ignoring the arab parties and work with them
Oppose Sharon and act
with courage, faith and a fighting spirit
Jimmy
--------- Forwarded message ---------- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Sat, 26 Jun 2004 01:59:07 +0200 Subject: Avnery on Labor Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Hi,
Hope this may interest you. Salamaat, Shalom, uri Uri Avnery26.6.04
“The
Starling Went to the Raven” An old, worn-out whore
who waits in vain for a man to seek her favors is a pitiful sight indeed. The
Israeli Labor Party is in this pathetic position, but it is difficult to feel
any pity for it. For months now, the
party has been waiting at the door of the Usually Shimon Peres
is blamed for this situation. Quite rightly, of course. Peres is longing for the
position of Foreign Minister the way a man dying of thirst in the desert longs
for water. As a member of the government he could meet with kings and
presidents, take part in international conferences, make solemn declarations and
do all the things that give meaning to his life. For him, life in opposition is
no life at all. But the question is:
Why was this man elected to his position as executive chairman of the party?
Those who elected him knew where he wants to go. After all, he has already
served as As the
chief of the largest parliamentary faction outside the governing coalition,
Peres is entitled by law to be addressed as the “Leader of the Opposition”. No
title could suit him less. While Menachem Begin, for example, flourished in
opposition and spent 29 happy years there, Peres wilts like a flower without
water. He has no idea what to do. If he were offered a plan for opposition
activities on a plate, he wouldn’t know what to do with
it. From the very
beginning of his career, as an instructor in the Working Youth movement, Peres
was a man of the government. As an assistant of David Ben-Gurion, as the
Director General of the Defense Ministry, as a minister and as Prime Minister –
he always identified with the government, worked for the government and
represented the government. When Ben-Gurion compelled him to leave Labor in 1965
and participate in the founding of the opposition Raffi party, he was miserable
and used the first pretext to rejoin the government. When he lost an election
and was stuck in opposition, he looked for the first opportunity to join a
“national unity” government. From this point of
view, Peres is a perfect symbol of his party. From 1933, when it assumed power
in the Zionist organization’s governing institutions, until the 1977 “upheaval”
which brought the Likud to power, Labor enjoyed 44 uninterrupted years in power.
Indeed, the Likud victory dumfounded everybody. Until that moment, nobody could
even imagine a government without Labor. At the time, a Member
of Parliament could not but pity the Labor members, who drifted along the
Knesset corridors like ghosts. When they mounted the rostrum to speak about some
subject, they automatically assumed the pose of government spokesmen and had to
remind themselves in mid-speech that it was, after all, their job to
criticize. Throughout the last
year one could hardly find a single sign that the Labor Party was in opposition.
True, it regularly submits no-confidence motions, but that is an empty weekly
ritual that is not taken seriously by anybody either in the Knesset or
outside. On no subject
whatsoever does Labor really fight the government. It identifies itself with the
Thatcherist economic policy of Treasury Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, which hits
the poor (who vote for the Likud anyhow) and serves the economic elite (which
belongs to the Labor Party). It cannot fight against the settlements, since
Peres himself founded the first settlement in the center of the
The close relations
between Shimon Peres and Ariel The very name “Labor
Party” is a misnomer – it is neither a party nor has it anything to do with
labor. It has no roots at all in four of the five major components of Israeli
society: the religious, the Oriental Jews, the new immigrants from
The party is in a
shambles. It has, in fact, no real local branches, only small groups of
interested functionaries. Worse: there are no signs of a new leadership, or even
new ideas, after the collapse of the old concepts. One sees only a group of
tired politicians, each of whom looks out only for himself, fighting to get a
few minutes on television, where he can repeat obsolete phrases from the past.
The public listens and yawns. It is these
politicians who elected Peres, because they could not agree on any other
candidate for party chairman. This is not a symphony orchestra, but only a bunch
of street musicians, each with his own tune in his
head. All this would not be
important, if it did not have such grave implications. The absence of a real
opposition creates a void in the political landscape and leaves the entire arena
to Sharon and his henchmen. The small Meretz party, now called “Yahad”
(“Together”) is no effective opposition either – not only because of its size,
but because it suffers from many of Labor’s afflictions. It does not take part
in the daily battles on the ground. It does not fight against the monstrous
wall. The Prime Minister’s bribery affair, which would have provided a field day
for any real opposition, did not evoke a reaction from Yahad. Labor, of course,
kept mum. The small parties that
represent the Arab citizens are much more active, but most of the Jewish public
ignores them, much as it ignores the Arab public in
general. This is a disastrous
situation. It sows despair among those who are longing for change but see no
viable substitute that can assume power. It explains the odd result of all
public opinion polls: the majority is ready to make sacrifices for peace, the
majority votes for A change of government
is impossible without a change of opposition. And a new opposition has a chance
of arousing enthusiasm only if its agenda is really opposed to the government’s
agenda. For that, courage, faith and a fighting spirit are needed.
Until such an
opposition comes to life, inside or outside the Labor Party, there is no chance
of real political change.
Yahoo! Groups Links
|
