for latest update:
http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/international/AP-Israel-Palestinians.html
?ex=1089601990&ei=1&en=ad174a8302cce0ac

Israeli Court Orders Changes to Barrier in West Bank

June 30, 2004
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS 

Filed at 8:41 a.m. ET 

JERUSALEM (AP) -- In a precedent-setting decision, Israel's
Supreme Court ordered the government Wednesday to change a
large section of its West Bank separation barrier, saying
the current route violates the human rights of the local
Palestinian population. 

The court said the changes must be made, even at the risk
of reducing Israeli security. The government said it would
honor the ruling. 

In the Gaza Strip, meanwhile, Israeli troops encircled the
northern town of Beit Hanoun, tearing up roads in an
ongoing offensive aimed at halting Palestinian rocket
attacks. A Palestinian teenager was killed, Palestinian
sources said. 

The court decision -- the first major ruling on the barrier
-- is expected to affect other sections of the contentious
separation barrier. It signaled the court would reject
other parts of the barrier that separate Palestinians from
their lands, cut villages off from each other or prevent
people from reaching population centers. 

``Only a separation route based on the path of law will
lead the state to the security so yearned for,'' the court
said in its ruling. ``The route ... injures the local
inhabitants in a severe and acute way while violating their
rights under humanitarian and international law,'' it said.


Israel says the barrier is needed to prevent suicide
bombers and other attackers from reaching Israeli towns and
cities. But the complex of fences, concrete walls, trenches
and razor wire has severely disrupted the lives of
thousands of Palestinians by separating them from jobs,
schools and farmland. 

About a quarter of the 425-mile barrier, which dips deep
into the West Bank in some sections, has been completed. 

Israel's Defense Ministry -- responsible for overseeing
construction of the barrier -- said it would re-route the
disputed sections of the barrier ``based on the principles
set by the Supreme Court, namely the proper balance between
security and humanitarian considerations.'' 

Wednesday's case focused on a 25-mile stretch of the
barrier northwest of Jerusalem, where 35,000 people live in
eight villages. The fence would separate the villagers from
7,500 acres, most of it cultivated, including tens of
thousands of olive trees, fruit trees and other crops. 

``To have the chief justice of the Supreme Court say you
can't put the Palestinians in prison ... in the name of the
security of Israel, that is really important. That is the
least I can say,'' said Mohammed Dahla, a lawyer for the
petitioners. 

He said the court had ordered changes in about 20 miles of
the stretch. Israel Radio said two miles of completed
construction would also have to be dismantled. 

The ruling said the route had ``severely violated'' the
local population's freedom of movement and ``severely
impaired'' their livelihoods. It described the villages as
being in a ``virtual chokehold.'' 

``For a whole year, we have been saying this and no one
listened to us,'' said Ahmed Kandill, a 30-year-old
resident of the Beit Surik village. 

Dany Tirza, the army's chief planner of the route of the
barrier, said he was ``disappointed and surprised'' by the
decision. The ruling will delay construction of the barrier
``by many months,'' he added. 

The court forced the government to return land that has
been seized and compensate the Palestinians for their
financial losses. 

The court froze construction of the section near Jerusalem
in late February, shortly after two protesters were killed
in a stone-throwing clash with soldiers in the path of
construction. 

Palestinian Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia played down
Wednesday's ruling. 

``The wall is an act of aggression whether it remains as
is, or they introduce changes in its route. This wall
should be knocked down as other walls in the world, like
the Berlin Wall,'' he said. 

The Palestinians have also asked the world court in the
Hague, Netherlands, to rule on the legality of the barrier.
The world court is expected to issue its advisory ruling
next week. 

In Gaza, meanwhile, Israeli troops encircled Beit Hanoun,
as part of a new offensive aimed at halting rocket attacks
into Israel. 

At one of the entrances to the town, a crowd threw stones
and empty bottles at Israeli troops early Wednesday. 

Soldiers opened fire, fatally shooting a 16-year-old boy in
the neck, Palestinian hospital officials said. Six
demonstrators were lightly wounded. 

Israeli military sources said the soldiers had fired in the
air, but that someone might have been hit by a ricochet. 

Security officials said the expected the operation to be
more devastating raids in the area, which turned large
farming areas into moonscapes, with thousands of trees
uprooted. 

The raid came in response to the first deadly rocket attack
from Gaza, which killed two people, including a 3-year-old
boy, on Monday. 

Prime Minister Ariel Sharon promised panicked Israelis in
the border area he would stop the barrages with
``wide-ranging actions.'' 

A new threat from Gaza could complicate Sharon's plan to
withdraw from the coastal strip by September 2005. More
rocket attacks could undercut what is now considerable
popular support for the plan. Despite the pledge, more
rockets fell in the border town of Sderot on Tuesday, as
Sharon was visiting. 


------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar.
Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free!
http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/MknplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
     http://groups.yahoo.com/group/VTJP/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
     [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
     http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to