Why Vote for Ralph Nader?

By Matt Gonzalez

These days it's popular, particularly in progressive circles, to attack
presidential candidate Ralph Nader and his running mate, Peter Camejo.
Votes for Nader would likely otherwise go to Sen. John Kerry, and so the
fear is that President Bush will be re-elected -- a possibility that
naturally engenders strong feelings. But why is the right solution to 
attack
Nader, who genuinely holds views different from those of Kerry and Bush?
After all, Nader and Camejo are simply running for public office in a
democracy.
The problem isn't that Nader and Camejo represent a duplicative 
platform, or
fail to address issues being ignored by the two major parties -- it's 
simply
that their running cannot be accommodated within our two-party system. 
So
the answer, for many, is that they shouldn't run. But why make the 
solution
an undemocratic one? Why not insist that the system be changed?
Do you really think it's an accident that the Democrats can't come up 
with a
solution to the spoiler problem? Ask yourself, have they spent four 
years
trying to reform the Electoral College? Or calling for majority 
elections so
that we don't get a repeat of Florida -- an election decided by a 
plurality
victory? Why blame Nader?
One need only look at the two major candidates for president to see how 
much
of a failure our political system is. On virtually every issue of
significance, the candidates appear to be in agreement.
For instance, they both supported the war in Iraq (although Kerry 
believes
Bush is mishandling matters and would like 20,000 more troops in the
region), and both supported the Patriot Act (arguably the worst attack 
on
civil liberties this country has seen in the last half-century). Both
opposed the Kyoto Accords, which would have begun to address global 
warming,
and both supported the World Trade Organization agreements, which 
subjugate
our national and local interests to international commercial ones. 
Neither
supports gay marriage, and even concerning the abortion question, Kerry 
says
he'll appoint anti-abortion judges to the federal courts (but he says 
he'll
make sure they don't want to repeal Roe v. Wade).
So, who is kidding whom? The progressives who are self-righteous in 
their
condemnation of Nader, or those who believe the Democrats are not an
opposition party?
Continuing to excuse the Democrats for not addressing the spoiler 
problem
only ensures that the problem will not get fixed. Excusing Kerry from 
making
concessions in this regard before you vote for him likewise ensures 
that the
problem will not get fixed. Participating in attacks on Nader for 
running
only props up an undemocratic system that must be reformed.
The stakes are not one presidential race, but rather whether a 
diversity of
ideas will ever reach Congress. Without this reform there will only 
ever be
one congressperson with the courage to oppose the war in Iraq. There 
will
only be one senator to vote against the Patriot Act. This state of 
affairs
is so bleak that pretending there is an opposition party in our 
two-party
system can only charitably be called foolish. I hate to say it, but it's
true.
Those who continue to say that Nader ruined the 2000 election ignore 
that
over 7 million Democrats voted for Bush -- 250,000 of them in Florida. 
They
ignore that 6,600 votes in Palm Beach were spoiled by a butterfly ballot
designed by a Democrat. Instead, they attack Nader, who has dedicated 
his
entire adult life to fighting for consumer and civil rights. He has 
been a
stalwart against growing corporate power. His running mate, Peter 
Camejo,
has written on post-Civil War Reconstruction and has been a pioneer on
socially responsible investing. The Nader/Camejo ticket offers voters
something very different.
Attack them all you want, but years from now Nader and Camejo's effort 
will
be remembered with Upton Sinclair's "End Poverty in California" 
campaign for
governor of California and with the presidential efforts of Norman 
Thomas,
Henry Wallace, Eugene Debs and Bob LaFollette. They will be remembered 
as
men who fought to make this a better democracy.
Matt Gonzalez is president of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors.
(Matt Gonzalez, "Why Vote for Ralph Nader?" San Francisco Examiner, 
July 14,
2004)



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
Yahoo! Domains - Claim yours for only $14.70
http://us.click.yahoo.com/Z1wmxD/DREIAA/yQLSAA/MknplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/VTJP/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to