On 29 Jan 2005, at 8:20 PM, Greg Sharp wrote:

Legally as far as Australia is concerned just about every person who owns an iPod is a criminal if you copy music to it. Any law that is so unjust as to make you or your kids a criminal just for copying music to an iPod should be
fought to the bitter end.

Is the apparent illegality of copying music to an iPod really a new problem? We've been doing it for years copying vinyl and CDs to tapes to protect the original or play them in the car. What about the rampant use of the VCR?

I for one would support the replacement of an ineffective copyright law with one which is practical. Surely you should have the right to copy a sound or video recording you have purchased to another device to play it back to yourself.

Changing the law can't be that difficult. What about a political campaign to press for a change in the copyright laws?

Regards,

John Taylor