Al Arifi and the Jerusalem Visit: Not All Bad!

By Dr. Hamad Al-Majid

"Dr. Mohammed al Arifi, the Lion of Islam and brave warrior, go in the name of 
God to Jerusalem and do not pay attention to trouble-makers." "Sheikh al Arifi, 
you are a man of initiative, and your visit to Jerusalem expresses support of 
the Prophet's Night Journey to Jerusalem and of the people of Jerusalem who are 
under siege and oppressed. So put your trust in Allah [and go to Jerusalem]."

These are just two of the numerous comments made by male and female fans of 
Sheikh al Arifi on a number of websites that tackled this interesting issue. Of 
course these youthful comments were made before Sheikh al Arifi announced that 
he would not be going to Jerusalem. He said that the whole matter was merely a 
misunderstanding and added that he could never visit Jerusalem as long as it 
remains under Zionist occupation. He further stated that he would never appeal 
to or beg the Israeli consulates to grant him an entry visa so as to perform 
prayers in Jerusalem. Sheikh al Arifi ended by stating that he would never 
enter Jerusalem except by the sword just as the Zionists seized it by the 

Sheikh al Arifi said that he had no intention of breaking Arab and Islamic 
consensus and taking an unprecedented step towards normalizing the Zionist 
occupation of Jerusalem. We could not have expected anything less from someone 
like Sheikh al Arifi who is known for his religious fervour. I believe it would 
be a waste of time to continue to blame and censure him after this 
clarification, despite whether his critics call it a correction, a retraction 
or clarification and despite whether or not it was convincing.

What we really ought to pay attention to and consider a cause for concern is 
the fact that many young Arab men and women, including the millions of fans of 
Sheikh al Arifi, approved of his visit to Jerusalem. Some of them welcomed the 
project as an indication of an actual visit to Jerusalem rather than merely 
viewing it from Jordan, as al Arifi stated. Those youth expressed their strong 
wish to see their beloved Muslim cleric perform his prayers in Al Aqsa Mosque.

These random and supportive comments are what should catch the attention of 
observers and analysts. It is quite worrying that a large number of young Arabs 
are completely oblivious to the reason why Muslim scholars, preachers, 
intellectuals, leaders and politicians do not go to Jerusalem and pray in Al 
Aqsa Mosque. Many of them have even asked, "What's wrong with praying in Al 
Aqsa Mosque?"

The only good thing about al Arifi's bombshell - regardless of the motivations, 
justifications, intentions and hidden facts behind it despite that it brought 
about strong anger across the Muslim world and was misunderstood by many as 
Sheikh al Arifi himself said - is that it gave us the opportunity to reopen the 
issue of anti-normalization with Israel and highlight the features and 
justifications of this position that will remain unchanged as long as Israeli 
troops continue to desecrate the sacred land of Jerusalem. Dozens of Arab 
satellite television channels dedicated hours of live broadcast to cover the 
issue of the Jerusalem visit and to explain its broad impact, danger and 
[potential] repercussions on the Arab-Israeli conflict. A number of Muslim 
sheikhs and scholars appeared on television and warned against this. It was one 
rare occasion where the entire intellectual and political spectrum including 
Islamists and liberals shared the same view and criticized the idea of a Muslim 
scholar visiting Jerusalem. Of course each camp had its own agenda, motivations 
as well as its announced and unannounced objectives for criticizing the 
potential visit.

Though the statement made by Sheikh al Arifi about visiting Jerusalem caused 
unease, discontent, confusion and strong reactions, it must be stated that it 
was not all bad. The question 'what's wrong with visiting Jerusalem' was 
finally answered in a detailed and comprehensive manner through debate, 
discussions, articles and fatwa shows in response to Sheikh al Arifi's proposed 
visit to Jerusalem. It was a good opportunity to shed light once again on the 
issue of anti-normalization with our Zionist enemy and to revive the idea among 
the younger generations that are sadly unaware of the significance of the 
anti-normalization campaign and the necessity of keeping it alive.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke