Politik tetap politik, kuman di seberang lautan berbeda dengan gajah di
halaman rumah sendiri. Pengetahuan ini semoga menjadikan kita lebih 
bijaksana" dalam melihat konflik di negara lain, tanpa diwarnai kebencian
atau kecintaan yang berlebihan.

Erdogan and the Israel Card
by Steven J. Rosen
Wall Street Journal
June 10, 2010
The deaths of nine Turkish citizens in the Gaza flotilla incident would have
brought a severe reaction under any circumstances. What is nonetheless
striking in this incident is the unbridled anger and fiercely hostile
reaction of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and the Turkish
public. Mr. Erdogan said Israel was guilty of "state terrorism" and a 
bloody massacre." His foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, said "This attack
is like 9/11 for Turkey," comparing it to a premeditated act of aggression
that took 2,900 lives.
Mr. Erdogan does not always display such reactions to allegations of human
rights violations. Last year, he defended Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir,
indicted by the International Criminal Court for killing half a million
Sudanese Christians and non-Arab Muslims. In March 2010, he denied that
Turks ever killed Armenian civilians. He labeled a U.S. congressional
resolution on the Armenian deaths "a comedy, a parody." He said that the
Turkish military garrison stationed in Cyprus since 1974 is "not an occupier
 but "[ensures] the peace." On tens of thousands of Kurds killed by Turkish
security forces from 1984 to 1999, he says nothing.
Could it be that there is something more to Mr. Erdogan's rage against
Israel than just a spontaneous reaction to the loss of life here?
Turkish elections, 13 months away, hold the answer. Backing for Mr. Erdogan
s party has fallen to 29%, the lowest level since it won power in 2002 and
far below the 47% it scored in July 2007. So Mr. Erdogan decided to play the
Israel Card.
He tested this tactic in January 2009, in a confrontation with Israeli
President Shimon Peres at Davos. Mr. Peres asked him in front of the
cameras: "What would you do if you were to have in Istanbul every night a
hundred rockets?" Mr. Erdogan shot back, "When it comes to killing you know
very well how to kill." Thousands of Turks applauded Mr. Erdogan's
performance, greeting him with a hero's welcome and a sea of Turkish and
Palestinian flags upon his return home to Ataturk Airport.
Mr. Erdogan's anger at the Israeli blockade is even more popular among his
countrymen. In fact, 61% of Turks surveyed in one poll did not find his rage
sufficient. "The public is in such a state that they almost want war against
Israel," the pollster commented. "I think this is widespread in almost all
levels of society." Mr. Erdogan has become a hero in the Muslim world, where
he is seen as the "new Nasser," in the words of one Saudi writer.
The truth is that friendship toward Israel was always limited to the Turkish
secular elites, including the military chiefs. Turkey is fertile ground for
Mr. Erdogan's demagoguery because many ordinary people are raised to dislike
Israel and¬ódare it be said¬óJews. In April 2010, the BBC World Service Poll
found negative views of Israel among 77% of Turks.
Jews as a people fare no better than the Jewish state. In the 2009 Pew
Global Attitudes survey, 73% of Turks rated their opinions of Jews as 
negative." Meanwhile, 68% of Turks rated their opinions of Christians as 
Turks don't like the United States much more than they do Israel. The same
BBC poll found negative views of the U.S. among 70% of Turks, one of only
two countries where perceptions of the United States actually worsened after
the election of Barack Obama (positives fell to 13% from 21%, and negatives
increased to 70% from 63%).
Nor is it the case that anti-Americanism in Turkey is primarily a response
to U.S. support for Israel. Many Turkish citizens view the U.S. as
anti-Muslim and see the war on terror as an anti-Muslim crusade across the
Middle East. Turks resent the rich "imperialist" superpower and believe that
the U.S. invaded Iraq for oil.
Islamists and the Turkish left suspect that the U.S. and NATO propped up a
succession of Turkish governments backed by the military. Others believe
that the U.S. supports the Iraqi Kurds and may plan to create a Kurdish
state in Iraq. And most remain convinced that members of the U.S. Congress
who vote for Turkish genocide resolutions do so under the influence of
Armenian-Americans, who are more numerous than Americans of Turkish origin.
Anti-American feelings in Turkey exist independently of anti-Zionism and
anti-Semitism, but these three phenomena are mutually reinforcing and
convergent. More disturbingly, parallels to these trends pervade much of the
Muslim world. What the flotilla incident demonstrates is that igniting this
tinderbox of hostility toward Israel, Jews and America does not take much of
a spark.
Mr. Rosen is the director of the Washington Project of the Middle East Forum

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke