Amanda Waite wrote:
> Jeff Trawick wrote:
>> sunanda menon wrote:
>>> Hi ,
>>> Please do a Code Review request for the upgrade of MySQL from 5.0.67 
>>> to 5.0.77 (CR 6808952)
>>> at http://cr.opensolaris.org/~sunandam/6808952/
>>>
>> it looks okay to me, though it would be good for somebody more 
>> familiar with packaging to have a look as well ;)
>
> I'd do it, but I'm used to doing reviews on sfwnv-discuss and you guys 
> might think some of the suggestions that I make are excessively 
> nit-picky.
What types of review comments are there (staying away from the term 
"nit-picky")?

* identification of changed code that introduces a problem (functional, 
legal, whatever)
** must resolve in the current review package before integrating
* identification of changed code that could be improved (maintainability 
and/or consistency)
** track via separate CR if integration is high priority and there's no 
time to resolve immediately
* identification of existing problem


Reply via email to