On Sat, 2003-03-01 at 13:45, Tavis Rudd wrote:
> Whoa, that is quite the rant.  Although I think he's wrong about the 90% and I 
> don't agree with splitting them off, he does have a point.  
> 
> When I was a beginning webware user it wasn't immediately clear that WebKit 
> was the core and could be used independently. Frankly, the alpha quality 
> stuff like UserKit *was* a turn-off.  This stuff isn't an issue to developers 
> that are already familiar with and using Webware, but it is a significant one 
> for those evaluating it or trying to convince the rest of their team to use 
> it.  A few prominent notices in the docs stating that 'WebKit is the core, 
> can be used independently, and has been tested most thouroughly' would go a 
> long way to countering misconceptions about relationships between the kits.

I agree.  As someone who is very new to Webware (1-2 weeks since I
learned about it) I did stumble over the kit layout a bit.  As a basis
for comparison I have used Tomcat before and found it easier to
understand on a conceptual level. I think it has something to do with
the way Webware is introduced or the naming convention.  For example,
the *kit naming convention does imply a level of equality that is
misleading. 

In short, I think WebKit should be renamed and presented separately from
the other "modules".  While I understand that Webware is a suite of
tools, I think WebKit is the key "product" in the suite that most people
will be interested in, and the other *kit's are generally for enhancing
WebKit (though very capable of being used seperately, I do not see this
is the most common situation).


To clarify, I currently see Webware a bit like this (I'm probably way
off on some of this):

WebKit: Python Application Server
MiddleKit: Object Abstraction Layer (I guess)
<insert name here>Kit: <insert name here> handling utilities

However, I do not feel the site/docs/whatever presents it quite this
way.  There are notes such as "Don't know where to start? Try WebKit",
but I do not believe that portrays things accurately.


Am I making any sense here?


[Note: As I said I am new to Webware. I could still be wrong about a
great many things.]


-Tom


Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part

Reply via email to