Matt Feifarek wrote:
> I don't think that breaking them apart increases release
> work. I don't
> think that COMKit for example should need to be rev'd each time that
> webkit is. Most of these bits should be quite stable, yes? So
> they just
> chug along as they are, throughout Webkit updates. Why make a new
> "release" of COMKit if none of the code has changed? This is how it
> seems to work now; we increment the version numbers on
> everything, even
> code that hasn't changed.

I did a couple of Webware releases, and I found that it was more work and
more confusing to have independent version numbers for each subcomponent
than it is to just increment everything in lock-step.  The version numbers
aren't that important anyway -- much more important is that the release
notes for each component are accurate.

> It's surely not my intent to "throw in a bunch of
> requirements". And I'd
> say that your point about "everyone's essentials" can be made about
> everyone's requirements. This is the discussion that I was hoping to
> generate... what should Webkit become next. I for one think that it
> needs form processing. I don't expect everyone to agree with me.

Actually, I agree that Webware should include form processing.  It doesn't
necessarily need to go into the very next Webware release.  I imagine that
both FunFormKit and ForkKit are both plenty mature enough that either one
could be merged into Webware.  That said, I haven't used either one and have
no particular opinion on which one would be more suitable. 

> There's another point of view that I find compelling: that webkit is
> basically "done" and only needs bug-fixes from here on out. That its
> flexibility is its power, so let's not go messing with it.
> I'm gathering
> that this is the point of view of you and other core members
> like Geoff.

I'm not opposed to adding widely useful stuff like form processing, improved
URL handling, built-in HTTP server (which I think is already there in CVS),
etc.

I'm not too happy with the state of CVS where it seems like a bunch of
rewritten code has been checked in to CVS -- and then there was never any
follow-through to thoroughly test it and push ahead to a new release.  As a
result, I don't know if the CVS head is as stable as the 0.8.1 code that I'm
using in production.

Oh and one other thing -- COMKit could probably be removed entirely and its
very minimal functionality could be folded into WebKit.  People see the
presence of COMKit and assume it actually has some functionality of its own,
but it doesn't really.  That probably causes some confusion to newbies.

- Geoff


-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.Net email is sponsored by OSTG. Have you noticed the changes on
Linux.com, ITManagersJournal and NewsForge in the past few weeks? Now,
one more big change to announce. We are now OSTG- Open Source Technology
Group. Come see the changes on the new OSTG site. www.ostg.com
_______________________________________________
Webware-discuss mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/webware-discuss

Reply via email to