On 7.5.2012 18:00, Boris Zbarsky wrote:
On 5/7/12 11:54 AM, Bronislav Klučka wrote:
"I see pages doing it is that they're up to no good" well that is your
opinion, sure, we have all seen bad use of that, but removing
functionality that has no replacement, can be used for useful thinks
(well for bad as well) can hardly be reasonable

Sure it can, if the abuse case is the overwhelming case. Browsers have done it before, and users were very glad they did.

-Boris

I'm not sure about whole functionality removed without replacement... You wrote to Tab "the legitimate use-case for popup windows is also reasonable, yet browsers have popup blockers." sure, but this functionality was not removed, etc... I can imagine no DOM/browsing context manipulation (even new browsing context) by default, only on opt in (but when the optin? before the beforeunload :) ?) But disabling it altogethe, because someone may alert "Do you really want to exit this page?"?

Brona

Reply via email to