The WHATWG mailing list is actually not an appropriate place for either
this kind of e-mail (I'm not even really sure what this e-mail was supposed
to be... are you an implementor?) nor your other recent e-mail (voting for
a feature doesn't help in the WHATWG, all that matters is the quality of
arguments and data presented).

I urge you to read the WHATWG FAQ before sending further e-mails to the
list. Thanks.

If you wish to respond to this e-mail please do not cc the WHATWG list in
your reply.

Ian Hickson

On Tue, Nov 29, 2016 at 11:46 PM Richard Maher <>

Contact emails


Secure, user-sanctioned geolocation collection is currently unavailable for
HTML5 Web-Apps when they are not running or in the foreground. This leaves
the browser hosted applications incapable of competing with Native Apps on
an even playing field.

The main goal of background geolocation reporting is to all web-apps, but
in particular, Gaming, Social-Network, and Fleet-Management Apps, to
continue to function even if the device has gone to sleep or another App is
in the foreground.

Additional goals are:


   Power-Saving. By using the existing ServiceWorker paradigm and flexible
   throttle/filter on which geolocation movements are "interesting".

   Single-process (Google Play etc) to monitor all geolocation reports for
   all Apps before deciding if ServiceWorker(s) need to be instantiated.

   Unlike Mozilla's current implementation, stalkers, estranged spouses,
   and marketeers will no longer be allowed to track users covertly.

Here is design overview document:
Ongoing technical constraints

None. See
Tracking bug
There is currently no top level bug.

*FOR MORE PLEASE SEE: - *!topic/chromium-dev/kDq4t93zbpA

Reply via email to