Hi,

as for moving RepeatingView to core, I'm +1 (for DataView too).

-Matej

Jean-Baptiste Quenot wrote:
Hi,

A while ago  I reported [1]issues with ListView,  and requested to
add  a remove  link to  the forminput  example to  demonstrate the
problem.  The problem was apparently [2]fixed by Eelco.

However the flaw is deeper than it appears: I proposed to [3]add a
remove *submit*  link to  allow one to  reproduce the  issue.  But
this didn't receive any attention so far.

Igor agreed  that « ListView  is fragile », and  that there  is an
alternative, namely RepeatingView.  But I reported that the latter
does  not  handle a  backing  List.   So  Igor advised  to  extend
RepeatingView to handle that.

What can  we do  to have  a better  ListView?  Are  you interested
in  a  rewrite  based  on   RepeatingView?   In  this  case  we'll
have  to  deprecate  ListView,   or  at  least  deprecating  using
ListView.setReuseItems(true),  which  means  deprecating  ListView
when  used in  a  form.   And we'll  also  probably  want to  move
RepeatingView from extensions to core.

WDYT?


Reply via email to