Gerard
Can you provide some URLs for these lists and blog postings please?
I think part of the problem may be that the information never reaches “ordinary
editors”. Communication channels on our projects are very poor. I read article
talk pages and the Australian Wikipedians Noticeboard, but not a lot of other
places.
However, I have a problem and I wonder if Wikidata can help with it. We have a
census in Australia every 5 years and the population data from the most recent
census (2011) is a standard item in every lede and infobox for any Australian
place (town/suburb/locality) article on en.WP at least. However, maintaining
that information is a massive tedious manual task. As a consequence, we still
have lots of articles with 2006 census data while the 2016 census is coming at
us like a freight train. The 2016 census will be the first one done primarily
online (normally we fill out a long paper form and so there are months of data
entry which delays the release of the data) and the data will be released
around mid-2017. Now all this population data is available as spreadsheets
under CC-BY license.
My question is this. Can we update these spreadsheets into Wikidata and then
create some kind of template on en.WP which can extract that data from
Wikidata. I am thinking something like:
{{CensusAUlatest|QLD|Childers}}
Which we could embed in, say, the lede and which would produce something like
In the 2016 Australian census, Childers reported a population of 12,345.
<ref>….</ref>
Where the 12,345 (and probably some components of the citation) would be
extracted from the 2016 spreadsheet entry for Childers. I’ve asked a few people
if this is possible to automate in this way and I get the standard response “it
might be but I don’t know enough about Wikidata”.
We have a similar problem with climate data where again we can probably obtain
spreadsheets with the data under a suitable license if we had a way to
automatically incorporate it into articles within the current massive manual
effort.
Do you have any advice for us? I am sure we are not the only nation with this
census problem, although I realise that in some countries the data may not be
released in suitable formats or with suitable licenses.
Kerry
From: Wiki-research-l [mailto:[email protected]] On
Behalf Of Gerard Meijssen
Sent: Friday, 20 November 2015 5:18 PM
To: Wikimedia Mailing List <[email protected]>; Research into
Wikimedia content and communities <[email protected]>;
WikiData-l <[email protected]>
Subject: [Wiki-research-l] Quality issues
Hoi,
At Wikidata we often find issues with data imported from a Wikipedia. Lists
have been produced with these issues on the Wikipedia involved and arguably
they do present issues with the quality of Wikipedia or Wikidata for that
matter. So far hardly anything resulted from such outreach.
When Wikipedia is a black box, not communicating about with the outside world,
at some stage the situation becomes toxic. At this moment there are already
those at Wikidata that argue not to bother about Wikipedia quality because in
their view, Wikipedians do not care about its own quality.
Arguably known issues with quality are the easiest to solve.
There are many ways to approach this subject. It is indeed a quality issue both
for Wikidata and Wikipedia. It can be seen as a research issue; how to deal
with quality and how do such mechanisms function if at all.
I blogged about it..
Thanks,
GerardM
http://ultimategerardm.blogspot.nl/2015/11/what-kind-of-box-is-wikipedia.html
_______________________________________________
Wiki-research-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l
