https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=49686
--- Comment #37 from kipod <[email protected]> --- (In reply to comment #22) > > If accidental insertion of wikitext is still an issue, we should focus on > other > ways to mitigate that issue. 2 things: 1) it's not an "if", and i do not think you guys should wait for the community to prove it to you. you should go hunt for it, so you can see for yourselves that it *is* an issue (hint: look for edits with "visualeditor" tag that added <nowiki>: approximately 100% of those represent the problems. you have to tools to actually measure it across all projects where VE is enabled by default). 2) "focus on other ways to mitigate that issue": how about solving bug 51897, instead of marking it "low" and basically ignoring it? this *is* exactly "other ways to mitigate that issue". or ,alternatively, find a better way to solve it: right now, it seems the team is saying "we'll focus on other ways to mitigate the issue", but they do not actually mean it: what other ways? who is working on it? what do they do? where is the "focus"? what you guys are doing today does not look very much like "focus" - it looks much more like ignoring the issue and hoping the problem will go away by itself. (In reply to comment #18) > Sorry, but this is not something we'll ever do, as I explained in comment 9. > It's not simply a matter of prioritization - it's a matter of ensuring we can > provide a user experience that's not modeled on markup, but on best user > experience practices. As James said, we provide keyboard shortcuts, and will > provide other user interfaces optimized for markup. But parsing markup within > the visual editing context is completely off the table. this is nothing more and nothing less than saying "it's so because i said so". you made a bad decision. that's something that happened in life to (almost) all of us. the problem is not so much this bad decision - the problem your refusal to accept that it was a bad decision, and you insistence that it was a good decision, in face of all the evidence. The reason i am writing this is because nowhere can i find any indication that the VE team actually changed its mind or at least decided to reconsider. it is very much possible that the team actually *did* decide to reconsider, and i just missed it. if this is the case, please be graceful and ignore my rant. peace. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are on the CC list for the bug. _______________________________________________ Wikibugs-l mailing list [email protected] https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikibugs-l
