https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=51698

--- Comment #13 from Peter Krautzberger <[email protected]> ---
(In reply to comment #12)

Thanks, Gabriel! That's very helpful.

> I'm also looking forward to learning more about LaTeXML vs. MathJax options.
> No browser supports Content MathML currently. The question then is if it is
> still useful to produce it for search while always rendering via Presentation
> MathML and/or server-generated SVG.

That's a good question. Especially, if Content MathML from TeX  can be good
enough (with "random" authoring instead of firm semantic guidelines).

> Copy&pasting entire formulas should be possible as long as our data-mw
> attribute on the outer wrapper node is preserved. That has the TeX source,
> which can be used to re-render the contents from scratch. This will enable
> copy&pasting of entire sections including formulas.

That would be awesome. Subexpressions seems impossible right now -- but one
day, with shadowdom and a lot of great heuristics it might just work...

> Are there popular screen readers that handle math? I agree that MathML is
> probably better in the longer term, but for current screen readers a speech
> string could still be a useful fall-back. At least if that would not prevent
> a plugin like math player from using the MathML instead.

A static speech string is never a bad idea for legacy screen readers. There are
only two math accessibility solutions, MathPlayer and ChromeVox. AFAIK a number
of screen readers ship MathPlayer but I'm not an expert on screen readers. 

Since ChromeVox is mostly JavaScript (and open source), an obvious idea is to
create a MathJax extension based on its technology.

The thing is that accessibility is about more than aural rendering; in
particular synchronized highlighting is extremely important for learning and
other non-vision disabilities. That can't work with static strings.

> I think nobody is suggesting to generate *only* SVG. 

I'm glad I misunderstood you :)

> I'm not sure about the need for reflow in Wikipedia, as the limits of texvc 
> seem to have motivated authors to handle this manually in TeX.

I seem to have a very different experience :( Anyway, right now PNGs are the
only option on mobile (bug 45816).

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are on the CC list for the bug.
_______________________________________________
Wikibugs-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikibugs-l

Reply via email to