https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=67526
--- Comment #11 from Florian <[email protected]> --- Ähm, is there any reason why you redirect the conversation in such way with these formulations and hostility? I think no, so please back to the normal conversation base we expect from each other :) > You know why that is? Because the mobile experience is just not good enough > for us to use. First i want to ask, who "we" is :) Like Maryana said, the decisions aren't made from only a feeling of some guy's sitting in black rooms and laugh about other people's annoyance. The decisions were made on base of analytics data from real Wikipedia users, editors and readers. And some (better. the most) of them use the Watchlist at it is, me too ;) So i'm very interested in to know who "we" is, maybe we overlook some user groups? This can only be clarified in conversation, not with reproach of some allegations. > you use that as justification for not fixing the UX for us. I think no! But, please consider and think about: If the data say, that many people use the UX like it is, what is, when we change it into a complete other way from today to tomorrow? That will generate a lot of frustration, that's not our score. But that doesn't mean this: > In other words, the people who made and still make what Wikipedia what it is > can go to hell. Thanks so much. Completly no! no no no :) I'm not long here, but one thing i learned (that not only in mobile team, thats's stands for all developers working at MediaWiki and the great extensions available for): All decisions and implementations must be for users, that includes readers and editors as well. If there is a voice of users say, that this and this must be changed or added as a new function or a change of a function, it will be changed or added, trust me :) So, the right way, before we can do anything, is: find the right way :D And for now, the analytics data, Maryana provided above, are that what we know from the big amount of users. So, if you have other voices, feel free, no: please!! give us this feedback :) (I'm "only" a volunteer, so it's my own opinion) -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug. You are on the CC list for the bug. _______________________________________________ Wikibugs-l mailing list [email protected] https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikibugs-l
