https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=30462
Web browser: ---
Bug #: 30462
Summary: The poll on personal image hiding feature is not
working.
Product: Wikimedia
Version: unspecified
Platform: All
URL: https://wikimedia.amellus.net/index.php/Special:Secure
Poll/vote/230
OS/Version: All
Status: NEW
Severity: normal
Priority: Unprioritized
Component: General/Unknown
AssignedTo: [email protected]
ReportedBy: [email protected]
CC: [email protected]
Classification: Unclassified
I saw a site notice that wmf wants input on an opt-in personal image hiding
feature.
Following it I got to a website describing the "feature" and telling that it
has already been decided to add it, instead of the expected poll, then sending
me back to the wiki in order to start the poll.
I do as requested and again I do not get to the poll but a page telling me that
again I must go elsewhere.
I go there, and I finally find a questionaire and yet another description,
telling me how to fill it in this time.
I have already spent more time on it than I was ready to give, but so as to not
make it a complete loss, I start reading the description, which appears not to
fit with the questionaire.
Ok, it is an apparent translation error which I find out a bit later, one of
the more common kind, one to happen automatically if the translator does not
see the page, of which he is only translating isolated sentences / words one at
a time.
I note that in the textareas below the questionaire in two languages.
I click radiobuttons, finding a question not making real sense, or being
usesless. I write down, in two languages, that it is so, and why I think it is.
I finish selecting radio buttons.
Having come to the conlusion that the idea of implementing something like that
in a multicultural and neutral way would probably mean not implementing it at
all, I decide that I should communicate that, too. I also came to realize that
I have immense doubt that having a small and simple list of possible selections
would be possible and would work out in reality - I should rather say that am
certian, it wouldn't be possible and that a list like that will rapidly grow
considerably beyond 100 items, if we only collect those fields of unwanted
materials that are - on a worldwise scale - well known to exist somewhere.
I write all this down in one language, adding a few dozen samples of categories
including one or two contries or cultures each, where this kind of materials is
generally deemed inappropriate content.
Then I translate it to the other language.
I reread everything and check that my answers are correct and my proses are
error-free.
I click the button to submit the questionaire.
Having read all this, you will understand my feelings of frustration and being
wasted when you read the next line which I quote verbatim:
> You've not been recognized by the system. Make sure that you've followed the
> instructions on How to vote page and that you've enabled cookies for this
> domain.
Trust me. I did all this. A quick try reveals: There is a timer built in. If
you do not answer quick enough, you're out. This is absolutely not acceptable.
Do you want quick and superficial answers? Do you want to forbid that people
may be interrupted and return later? What is this good for?
And by the way, the error mesage appears like wrong English to me.
Closing my test-window, I return to the result page from above. The bowsers
"back" button usually would bring me back to the filled questionaire, which I
then can resend with a freshly set timer. Not so this time - tha page is made
in a way inhibiting the "back" button to do anything useful, or retain the
previously entered data.
This is the 3rd time if I recall it right that I report this or a similar sort
of not-a-bug-but-rather-some-sort-of-intentional-sabotage about a poll run by
the wmf.
I for one currently expect me not to participate in such polls any more.
--
Configure bugmail: https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug.
You are on the CC list for the bug.
_______________________________________________
Wikibugs-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikibugs-l
