Spinster added a comment.

  In T282719#7088419 <https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T282719#7088419>, 
@John_Cummings wrote:
  
  > Hi Sandra
  >
  > I've updated the description to include the FRBR model as the basis for 
creating and matching items. Is it logic to say that new items the based on 
ISBN number (or other similar ID) should be Instance='edition' in Wikidata?
  
  No, you're trying to simplify something that is not that simple.
  
  On Wikipedia, which only uses text strings, I guess it's fine to take an ISBN 
number and then use a database to look it up and retrieve strings of text to 
build up a (single) reference. On Wikidata, where we are dealing with 
multilingual structured data, a 'book' is a cluster of sometimes dozens of 
multilingual layered entities.
  
  To make it very clear, as I think I didn't succeed in doing that with my 
earlier comment: I think it is NOT a good idea to ask for a tool for this. It's 
not simple matter that should be automated. This is stuff that needs 
knowledgeable human review.
  
  If someone has a ISBN number and wants to 'have that ISBN on Wikidata', they 
should need to do at least the following checks (and this list is 
non-exhaustive; I'm actually not a librarian so I will probably miss important 
things and get some things wrong):
  
  - Is there already any work-level and/or edition-level item that corresponds 
with the book? If so, any new items need to correspond correctly with the 
existing ones. If not, new items need to be created for both levels.
  - A check needs to happen whether the ISBN is of a translation. Maybe we 
already have Wikidata items for the (original language) work, and/or for an 
edition of a translation in another language. If that is the case, correct 
connections need to be made.
  - The book needs *both* a work-level item and an edition-level item. (This is 
exactly what FRBR is about.)
  - Both the work item and the edition item need the correct statements in the 
right place: author, publisher, date of publication and other metadata. 
Correctly. I don't know of any centralized databases that get this stuff right 
where we can retrieve this; this step probably needs deeper human research than 
just a check with a (any) database. Worldcat is (in my experience) pretty messy 
at this point so please do NOT use Worldcat as a sole source.
  - If lookups on Wikidata need to happen for the right author and publisher, 
that needs to be done _with care_ - if the author, is, say, named John Johnson 
where we have dozens of people with a similar name, a thorough check is needed 
to make sure the right one is chosen. In my experience, it is always best to 
actually go on Wikidata and do a bit of (non-tool) research at this point, 
because there may be items for humans with just initials or with a slightly 
different spellings that can't be caught by a tool.
  - If an item for the author/publisher is not found, should a new one be 
created? I'm not sure - there's so much opportunity for introduction of errors 
and duplicates here.
  
  Let me state it very clearly: I'm not a fan of this task at all. I think 
describing books on Wikidata is simply too complex for a single-purpose tool. 
If describing books correctly is an intricate piece of reality that needs a few 
years of education in library science, then it's not something that we can 
magically simplify on Wikidata by 'toolifying' it.

TASK DETAIL
  https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T282719

EMAIL PREFERENCES
  https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/settings/panel/emailpreferences/

To: Spinster
Cc: Seppl2013, Fuzheado, Pigsonthewing, Gamaliel, Spinster, Rhagfyr, 
Antoine2711, Jklamo, NavinoEvans, Aklapper, John_Cummings, Invadibot, 
maantietaja, Mohammed_Sadat_WMDE, Akuckartz, apaskulin, Nandana, lucamauri, 
Zambujo, Lahi, Gq86, valerio.bozzolan, GoranSMilovanovic, Chicocvenancio, 
QZanden, LawExplorer, _jensen, rosalieper, Scott_WUaS, Izno, Wikidata-bugs, 
aude, Daniel_Mietchen, Jhernandez, jayvdb, Mbch331, bd808, Krenair, Tgr
_______________________________________________
Wikidata-bugs mailing list -- wikidata-bugs@lists.wikimedia.org
To unsubscribe send an email to wikidata-bugs-le...@lists.wikimedia.org

Reply via email to