Jc3s5h added a comment.

The discussion of this in //Land Surveyor Reference Manual// 2nd ed., Andrew L. 
Harbin, Belmont CA: Professional Publications, pp. 1-8 through 1-10 agrees with 
my own experience. My experience includes creating voltage and current test 
specifications for mainframe computer chips.

A measurement usually contains a number of digits for which there is no doubt, 
which has a similar magnitude as the uncertainty. Unless an unusual effort has 
been made to nail down the amount of uncertainty, it is worthless to include 
more than one uncertain digit in the quantity. If the uncertainty is important 
for the way the quantity is being used, the uncertainty will be specified 
explicitly, but for less critical use, it will be implied by only including one 
uncertain digit. So for less critical uses, 10.2±0.05, 10.2±0.1, or 10.2±0.4 
would all be written 10.2. This does not lend itself to converting to an 
interval such as [10.1, 10.3]. Tough. The source decided not to record enough 
information to create that interval, so we can't.

Another point is that it is not normal in engineering or science when doing 
unit conversions, to try to keep traces of the original source units by keeping 
excessive significant digits in the uncertainty. If, for example, 10.2±0.2 m 
were converted to feet, it would be expressed as 33.5±0.7 ft. One reason for 
not attempting to keep traces of the original source units is that a 
calculation may contain units from several sources. For example, for a while in 
the US federally funded highway projects had to use metric units. The units 
going into a particular dimension might have come from a design value in 
meters, a distance measured in 1965 in feet, and an 18th century road with in 
rods. Following a non-standard procedure that only works for the simplest of 
calculations seems like a bad idea to me.

I would also mention that a quantity can be both approximate and exact at the 
same time. For example, the population of each state in the US is approximate; 
the Bureau of the Census does their best, but an exact count is just not 
feasible. But the count is treated as if it were an exact number when 
determining how many representatives in Congress each state gets, because 
attempting to treat the counts as approximations would just lead to endless 
bickering, if not another civil war.


TASK DETAIL
  https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T105623

EMAIL PREFERENCES
  https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/settings/panel/emailpreferences/

To: Jc3s5h
Cc: Jc3s5h, thiemowmde, kaldari, daniel, Stryn, Lydia_Pintscher, 
Liuxinyu970226, Snipre, Event, Ash_Crow, mgrabovsky, Micru, Denny, He7d3r, 
Bene, Wikidata-bugs, Ricordisamoa, Kelson, MSGJ, Klortho, Wolfvoll, Aklapper, 
aude, Malyacko



_______________________________________________
Wikidata-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikidata-bugs

Reply via email to